To all 4 of my neighbors, and to the lady in the commissary last Friday...The next time I see you scream at your kids, or yank on their arms, or treat them worse than you treat your dogs, I am going to put you on the ground, call the MP's and hope to god they take those kids away.
To the lady in the commissary, who slapped her son (about 8 years old) in the face - really hard - the only reason I didn't do anything is because I didn't want you to take him back home and hurt him even more.
There are some great parents here on post, but I have never in my life seen so many people treat their kids like total and utter crap.
It's amazing how, if you treat your children with respect, they will do the same for you.
I am watching you, and have my phone ready. The MP's are on speed dial.
While I agree that you should respect your kids and treat them right I just want you all to look at it from the mom's point of view.
We are all military and we live a very unstable and stressful life. Our children especially are feeling that homelife is unstable and they are stressed out as well. Do you know what lead up to that woman slapping her child?? NO!!!! Some children just have what I like to call a dynamic personality and no matter what you do they act up. You don't know if that woman has had any sleep, or any help or is her husband deployed or just got back you have no clue what that woman goes through in life and with that child. We live a very isolated life with no family connections or community of any type. Most of us sit on the computer all day just for conversation. I'm not saying what that lady did was the best decision but was she just trying to get out of the commissary because she's been there (dealing with this kid) for the past two hours? No one but this mother knows what was really going on. And I just want you all to look at this from HER point of view. And have a little more compassion for the situation.
And I disagree with the statement if you respect your kids they will respect you. I respect my kids and they don't always respect me. Kids are kids and they are going to do what they want to do. Some kids are great and are very well behaved and then there's some who are more sensative to everything and they act out no matter what. I feel very sad for the lady in the commissary you know she was very very frustrated. Please have some compasion for this woman and for the others, they are hurting in some way. And no it's not right to take out that hurt on the children, but everyone cracks. Something has to give. And if you're one of these mom's seek some sort of community. We have tons of resources and get a break from your kids, go to church, call someone.
If you're not one of these moms pray for them, make friends with these women. Put yourself in her shoes.
If you don't agree with me I don't really care. I've been that woman before and there is no help. You just have to be creative and learn self-control (no i've never hit my kid) but this military life is rough. And no one talks to anyone or makes friends anymore. It's sad really so here we are far from our friends and family trying to life and raise children. No one is perfect!
We are all military and we live a very unstable and stressful life. Our children especially are feeling that homelife is unstable and they are stressed out as well. Do you know what lead up to that woman slapping her child?? NO!!!!
As a woman with a deployed husband and as a woman who was BEAT from the time she was 5 until the time she was 18... NO amount of stress should EVER lead you to hitting your child. I do believe that spanking is acceptable, but to hit a child in the FACE?! ARE YOU OUT OF YOUR MIND?!?!?! Take an anger management class, because you should NEVER take that anger or stress out on your child!! That is beyond ridiculous. You are right we have TONS of resources for moms that are stressed, so I will NEVER EVER condone that behavior from a GROWN woman!! My husband is deployed and I am stressed, but the LAST thing I would do is beat my child for it!!! So, Maybe you should put yourself in he CHILDS shoes who is ALSO stressed and is now wondering "why doesnt my mom love me?" AND it also leads to children thinking that ABUSE IS NORMAL... I know from PERSONAL experience. And after SEVERAL abusive relationships, have found a great man. But are you saying that if my husband is stressed out and has nothing else he can do, he can just hit me?!?! I THINK NOT!!!!
This is ridiculous. I hope that one day all the women and men who beat their children will be locked away and these children can find peace and love in a home that has been waiting for a child!!! I always dreamed that would happen for me...
Actually, being military the mother must obviously have Tricare who covers mental health and family services. She shouldn't have to resort to smacking her child and if she feels she's getting to that point she needs to seek help, there's no shame in asking for help.
I also agree that in order to receive respect, you must first give it. I speak to my daughter courteously and she's learning to do that same to me and others. We shouldn't have to resort to treating our children like this.
Reina -you have a very good point. I have been there to where my child wanted to throw a temper in the middle of the store and in front of everyone. and yes I do pop my kids for getting out of line but I dont leave marks. (there is a difference)How I raise my kids and how the lady down the street raises her or the next are all different. Some will let their kids walk all over them. Some will raise their hands at them and some will raise their voices at them. Everyone is different with different views.
Our children especially are feeling that homelife is unstable and they are stressed out as well. Do you know what lead up to that woman slapping her child?? NO!!!!
Yes Reina that is a valid point military life is stressful for both the parents and kids. Is that a valid reason to slap the snot out of your kids in public? No its not. Just like F.A.W said there is no reason that justifies physical abuse. I do believe in spanking and grounding but I also believe kids will get away with any behavior as long as you allow it.
And I disagree with the statement if you respect your kids they will respect you. I respect my kids and they don't always respect me. Kids are kids and they are going to do what they want to do. Well again this falls on YOU as a parent. Kids will try to test your limits and if you dont stand your ground they will walk all over you. Respect is something they learn as soon as they are able to learn to talk and walk. They learn to speak how you teach them to speak. They learn to act according to how they see the parents act. So if your kids are disrespectful, who do you think they learn it from? I have my own kids my oldest is 9 and he knows better than to disrespect me or anyone else. I teach them you treat people as you want to be treated. Plain and simple.
Now if the lady is having a bad day she should have found someone to watch her kids for a minute so she can get some "me"time. The help is out there as long as you are willing to ask for it as well as receive it when it is offered.
As women, mothers, and wives we have all found ourselves in HER shoes. Is it ok to do this to our children? Hell NO! FAW said it loud and clear: But are you saying that if my husband is stressed out and has nothing else he can do, he can just hit me?!?! I THINK NOT!!!!
This is ridiculous. I hope that one day all the women and men who beat their children will be locked away and these children can find peace and love in a home that has been waiting for a child!!!
I think that somepeople not all look at it differently and take it out of portion. If your 11 or 14 back talks you or gets smart with you when you ask a question then yes I do not see why not they should not get popped in the mouth. It teaches them hey I should have not said that. and if your toddler throws a trantrum and falls out on the store floor and you grab them to pick them up and they pull back from you, yes it does look like you are yanking on their arm but really not. It is how you look at it.
Do you know what lead up to that woman slapping her child?? NO!!!!
I don't give a DAMN what lead up to it...he was about 8 years old, there is NO excuse for slapping him full force. I don't care if he told her to F*CK OFF. There is no excuse for treating your kids like sh!t. They didn't ask to be your children!!!!! If you can't control yourself you do NOT need to be raising kids. PERIOD!
I don't give a DAMN what lead up to it...he was about 8 years old, there is NO excuse for slapping him full force. I don't care if he told her to F*CK OFF. There is no excuse for treating your kids like sh!t. They didn't ask to be your children!!!!! If you can't control yourself you do NOT need to be raising kids. PERIOD!
Sorry but if my child would have said this yes, yes I would slap him/her. No child should ever tell their parent that. That is a lack on the parents part to teach the child respect.
Again kids learn from what they see, YOU are setting the example. If your kids are disrespectful, rude and have no manners its because that is what the have learned from YOU the parents. So don't take it out on them if you didnt know how to raise them.
Tiffany-like it was said before if the child does that it just means that the parent is the one to blame. No child is to talk like that to any adult. It is a lack on the parent side and that child needs to be dealt with. So if that means to hit them I do it. I dont mean leave a mark but a good hit from the parent will let the child know. I have an 11 year old 9 year old and a 2 year old and none of them talk that way to me or any adult. I was raised from the old school and I will raise my kids like that.
I agree that the parent is at fault. I don't understand how the parent is justified to hit the kid in the face. If the parent isn't teaching the child how to act why take it out on the kid. There are other ways to teach a child correctly. Leading by example for one. Teaching kids respect and rules goes along way. I am not anti spanking, it has it's place in discipline. I find it hard to believe that if a parent isn't doing there job that coming in and smacking your kid is going to be a behavior changer. Teaching kids that their actions have consequence from an early age makes a difference.
YOUR child is a prodigy of YOU!!! Thats right, if your child is misbehaving (which all children do) its how you handle it which will make the difference. Slapping the child isn't going to help, all thats teaching him/her is to live in fear, and do it behind your back (whatever he did).
If you don't want your child acting up, raise them right. Don't take the easy way of discipline, parenting actually takes work!!!
Also for the person who said being in the military is stressful, you are correct, BUT it was you and your husband who made that decision, not the child, so I suggest you deal with it, and not put that on a child!
I agree, I spank, I have let everyone on here know that I do, I am not ashamed of it, but hey my children are also not the ones running rampid in wal-mart. I don't have to get on to my kids that much any more, they are 9,7, and 3. They are going to test you in many ways, but when it comes down to it, if you correct it now the problem wont be as big later on down the road.
People are always going to try and stand over you and try and tell you how to parent. I say f*em, only you know your children and know how to deal with them. BUT there are some of those moms that need a little help in the right direction.
At this point I think everyone is a little too involved in each others buisness, and how people parent. Quick to judge. My thing is if you can't do right in your own home you have no buisness trying to tell others what to do in theirs DISCLAIMER
**** This is not directed to anyone, just an opinion****
I have never been so tired or frustrated that I have felt the need to slap, "pop in the mouth", or hurt my child.
I am certainly not someone whose children 'walk all over them'. My kids have always known what the rules of our house are, and when the rules have been broken, but they have been taught this in a respectful way.
If your toddler throws a fit on the floor of the commissary, tell them you'll be just down the aisle buying carrots or whatever, and go on about your business, always keeping them in your view. If they see that you don't react at all to their tantrum, they will stop having them.
Honestly, I don't have a lot of compassion for the mom in the commissary who slapped her child. She is (theoretically) an adult who should be able to control herself. I pity her child for loving her despite how she treats him.
Slapping someone in the face is literally one of the most insulting, degrading things you can do. How dare some of you do that to your children.
Slapping someone in the face is literally one of the most insulting, degrading things you can do. How dare some of you do that to your children.
My mother taught us this from day one. Kinda off subject, but it seems to be "acceptable" for females to slap males across the face for wrong doings. You see it all the time on tv. However, my mother taught us that if you put yourself in a man's position by slapping him in the face, be prepared to be hit back. Looking at it from that POV makes you think twice about doing it huh?
I don't agree with the "stress" excuse - my kids push my buttons DAILY and there is always AT LEAST one (possibly more) testing my patience at any given time. I am incredibly stressed 99% of the time - I have 5 kids ages 9 and under - the oldest two have special needs (which adds 100x more stress to the equasion) in addition to a deployed hubby. So do I slap my children across the face? NOPE. Stress is a cop out. We are all stressed. Military life sucks. Deal with it or move on. Don't take it out on your kids.
Now, I am not to say my children never misbehave - anyone who knows me well is very aware of some of our challenges around the house. I do spank them as needed, but I also deal with discipline in a variety of other ways as well. I am all for each household handling things in the ways that best suit their lifestyle, but there are occasions (such as this face slapping incident) that I feel cross the line between discipline and abuse. The fact that this was done in public makes you wonder what goes on at home behind closed doors. Also there is the psychological "humiliation factor" that hasn't been mentioned yet - emotional abuse can be just as detrimental as physical abuse - in some cases, even worse as emotional scars sometimes never heal. idk. i am rambling... i guess my point is that being at your breaking point is not an excuse for slapping your kid across the face. if my kid told me to f-off then he/she would be getting their mouth cleaned out with listerine. it is a non-preferred healthy alternative to soap. and their breath smells good in the end. LOL.
To all 4 of my neighbors, and to the lady in the commissary last Friday...The next time I see you scream at your kids, or yank on their arms, or treat them worse than you treat your dogs, I am going to put you on the ground, call the MP's and hope to god they take those kids away.
Well I find you post hard to followand I mean no disrespect at all. You want to advocate for children but will stoop to the same kind of violence you just witnessed against children?
This will teach the child nothing more than what Mommy teaches. Along with that you as a stranger just laid my Mom out on the floor (more violence) which probably will scare the kid to death worse than the slap on the face.
If you witness such again call the MPs 239-MPMP, explain you just witnessed excessive force being used against a child or suspected child abuse. Follow the patron until the MPs arrive and give your statement.
If the woman is done shopping and starts to leave follow ( at a distance so she has no clue) and write the license plate down, be prepared to give a statement. If nothing else it will perhaps put the spotlight on them and SWS will have them on their radar for future problems or they may already be in the systemand that act may give them reason to get the poor child out of their care.
Not acting on something because "you are afraid the parent may do more when the child gets home is questionable. Think of it this way, if she was willing to slap the child wish such force in public-- I can't imagine what she is already doing in the comfort of her home without witnesses.
If we all behave like mandated reporters it will help reduce the violence against children IMO.
Wow, everyone on here is getting too hype, lol. Yall lets breathe. I'm with mil.brat, I'm from the old school too. My son is very respetful. I wouldn't do things in public now days because you might get locked up, lol. But if I should ever had to snatch my child up or get in his face (NOT YELLING-calm down yall) I would hope no one would try to confront me about it. As a parent we know right from wrong. It's just too bad that things get out of hand for some folks. Personally I mind my business. Oh and hitting a child in the face as if they were a grwon person is wrong.
if my kid told me to f-off then he/she would be getting their mouth cleaned out with listerine
Ok, I was pretty mad when I wrote that and was replying to the lady who made it sound like there was an excuse for what that mother did. I have washed my kids mouths out with soap before, they were very young and it taught them early not to say bad words. If that boy did say that to his mom it would be a reflection of his raising and again would be on the mom. There is NO excuse for "snapping" on your children. I have walked away from a situation for a few minutes to calm down more times than I can count, but I have never demeaned or hurt them. Spanking is a completely different thing, we are talking about full force punishment and trash talking your kids. It's just disgusting and detrimental to the children. Like I said before, they didn't ask to be your kids. Children are a privilege and a blessing and should be treated with Love.
We are all military and we live a very unstable and stressful life.
If this is your excuse for poor parenting than get out of don't have kids. Simple as that. Your kids should come first, you will never get this chance with them again, you only get to raise them once. Is that really something you want to screw up?? Do NOT use the military as an excuse. I was 17 and my husband was 19 when we got married and a year later had our first of three babies and I was/am a damn good mom. That was a CHOICE I made when we decided to have kids. All of the "excuses" you listed are just that.
I just want to say...I believe isn spanking but not slapping a kid in the face, head or anything like that. The bottom is the place for that and only because they did something really wrong. I probably spanked my kids a total of twice per child in their lifetime and they are all teens now. But I absolutely HATE when people use being a military spouse as an excuse. I mean an excuse for ANYTHING. Yep it is a hard life style but YOU and your spouse chose it. Life in general is tough, people that arent in the military have it hard. Many of them dont have health insurance, a home, food, utilities and the other basic comforts of life. So let me just say that just because you are a military spouse doesnt mean you have a lock on life being tough. Life is as tough as you make it. MOVE ON and put your big girl pants on. DISCLAIMER: YOU's are in General...dont think this is about YOU unless the shoe fits.
I absolutely HATE when people use being a military spouse as an excuse. I mean an excuse for ANYTHING. Yep it is a hard life style but YOU and your spouse chose it.
I became a first time parent while my husband was deployed, that did not give me the right to abuse my child. I may have took too many 5 minute cigarette breaks to calm down at times, but if that's what it takes for me to be able to properly care for my child then so be it. I do believe in spanking if you know your limits.
I know what it's like to be physically and mentally abused by a parent, that's why I don't speak to my dad period. I can't stand to be in the same room as him. I learned from his mistakes and I don't plan on continuing the cycle.