Riley Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Riley bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for sale near Fort Riley courtesy of Military Real Estate!

bankruptcy

who's talking here?

BadLuckMommy 1
notsue 2
Brianna 2
Tee C 1
blahblahblah 4
Are we done yet 1
EastCoast 1
wifey9089 3
mysoldiershot 8
toriT 1
Cookie 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

mysoldiershot --- 14 years ago -

First I do not need nor want any snide, catty mean or negative remarks. So please if youre going to do that just dont comment. I am looking for info on filing bankruptcy. My husband had his identity stolen a couple years back and its just impossible to get everything cleared off his credit and im tired of bill collectors coming after us. We have went to JAG, filied police reports, applied an id fraud alert on all credit reports. But we are done. He wants to file bankruptcy, he is getting out in less then year so we are aware of it effecting the army and other potential jobs. But this is something that needs to be done. Does anyone have tips, suggestions, how much it costs, how long it takes etc? Did you do it here in Kansas? Or your home of record. Thanks 

notsue --- 14 years ago -

Its been ages since I've done it, and I wouldnt do it again. After 7-10 years whatever bad has happened will go away with or without bankruptcy... filing just makes that 7-10 start now instead of when whatever bad happened. Sure some people will give you a break after a few years from a bankruptcy and help you get credit again... but I'd rather avoid it all together. I'm happy living the cash life now and in 2014 my slate will be clean for the third time in my life. Best of all, I wont have to spend any money or time dealing with the headache of a bankrupcty.

Hope you find the help you are looking for tho, it is annoying when its not your fault that you are in a situation. 

EastCoast --- 14 years ago -

I haven't done it but was super close after my divorce a few years back and I did talk with a bankrupcy lawyer in Junction. If anything I suggest you do that. That way you have the correct information and you aren't just going off of what others say. It's fine to get other's experiences but you'll see that they differ. Some will say that they got their tax refunds taken every year afterwards while others will say that never happened to them etc. The lawyer told me that you won't see a refund for a while if you do file in KS. Every state is different so I would def. talk to a lawyer first and then go from there.

It was about $2500 to get it done here in KS unless you go the other route where you still continue paying your debts for a few years and then whatever you owe at the end is forgiven. That was about $500. You have to go to Topeka to get everything done. I hear that the lawyers in Topeka are a lot cheaper than ones in JC/Manhattan since they are local. You'll have to go to a series of credit counseling and submit bank statements for the past 6 months. Again, this is for filing in Ks, not sure about other states. I know it's a tough decision. Good luck. 

BadLuckMommy --- 14 years ago -

I did talk with a bankrupcy lawyer in Junction. If anything I suggest you do that. That way you have the correct information and you aren't just going off of what others say.

I agree with this 100%. I have no experience with this situation, but I can tell you that there are alot of people that give different information and for a situation as important as this I would seek legal advice. 

blahblahblah --- 14 years ago -

I filed a couple years back and it was the smartest thing I could have done. I know many ppl will say it is a bad idea, but like anything else, there will be different outcomes with different situations. I owed something like $250,000 in credit cards, forclosed house, reposessed car and student loans. We were living paycheck to paycheck trying to slowly pay off these debts, we started to do bankruptcy, a few years prior to finally commiting, even payed a lawyer and did all the work, just to back out at the last minute, we lost about $1200 in lawyer fees at that time. We were just unsure about what to do, and heard all the horror stories. But after we settled on it and decided to just do it, we got it all done within a few months, and after 2 years, our credit score is in the 700s, we have 2 car loans at 4.5% APR and got a Starcard with a $4000 limit (we dont use it). It is not for everyone, that is for sure, but it is for a lot of ppl. I had a great experience with it, and if you decide to do it, I hope you have a great experience too. You can do it here in kansas, you dont have to go back to your home of record. By the way, I was able to get a secret security clearance 1 year after the bankruptcy, so dont worry about the Army punishing you for doing it. Feel free to contact me if you have any questions. 

mysoldiershot --- 14 years ago -

thanks everyone. we are defintely getting lawyer advice before doing anything. i was looking for others that had or are filing for it. Im trying to decide what the best route would be for us. Im still on the fence with bankruptcy but at this point it looks like it may be our only option 

wifey9089 --- 14 years ago -

I've never filed, but my parents did when I was a kid and they regret it. It was years and years of having no options because of the bankruptcy.
It would take less time to get the identity theft fixed than for the bankruptcy to stop controlling your life.
Don't let the jerk who stole your husband's identity ruin your credit future any more with a bankruptcy. 

mysoldiershot --- 14 years ago -

thanks blah 

mysoldiershot --- 14 years ago -

wifey you really think it takes less time? we have been working 8 years on getting his identity theft fixed. His credit score is 430 from this ! Cant get much worse then that. I apperciate everyones comments, and are taking them all into cosideration. However we are still going to talk to a lawyer. Also how long ago was it that your parents filed? 

Brianna --- 14 years ago -

I had identity theft in 2001. There were huge loans, cars, mortgages, credit cards, etc. They had a great time and sold my information to others to use. I hired a lawyer and PI and within a few months I had a new SSN and other documents. Bankruptcy was not an option for me because of some personal beliefs. 

mysoldiershot --- 14 years ago -

i wish it was that easy for us. each time we (jag and our lawyers)try clearing something up something else comes up. Its so bad the lawyers are trying to get my hubby a new ssn. So they all arent as quick and easy. I wish it was though 

Brianna --- 14 years ago -

I knew one of the people and they investigated from there and found the ring leader. Mine ended going to court, so each is different. My case is pretty extreme compared to the ones you hear about. 

mysoldiershot --- 14 years ago -

yeah my husbands is extreme. cars, a house, EVERY credit card possible and when i say every i really mean it. Iternatioal loans, apartments, untilites, checking account, they even got into his aafes star account and our bank accounts. Its bad. Alot of it was taken to court but since hes military (And the courts were out of state) we didnt have to show up. 

Cookie --- 14 years ago -

I owed something like $250,000 in credit cards, forclosed house, reposessed car and student loans

How did it effect your student loans? 

blahblahblah --- 14 years ago -

How did it effect your student loans? 


I was able to settle the student loans. They do not go away with bankruptcy. 

toriT --- 14 years ago -

After 7-10 years whatever bad has happened will go away with or without bankruptcy... filing just makes that 7-10 start now instead of when whatever bad happened.

Just wanted to make sure that everyone knows debts don't just "go away." Whoever you owe money to will no longer be able to report it after X amount of time, but you still owe it, and they can still ask for it.
I had an ER visit when I was 16 that went under my SSN even though I was a minor, and even though it has been well over 7 years and is no longer on my credit report that hospital will not see me (unless for an emergency, that's the law) and they can still send me mail asking for payment. 

Cookie --- 14 years ago -

How did you settle your student loans? If you had $50K in loans, did you not still have to pay $50K? 

blahblahblah --- 14 years ago -

I was able to settle the student loans for less than I owed since it was in collections. It is difficult but possible, just have to talk to the right ppl. 

blahblahblah --- 14 years ago -

toriT is absolutely right. You cannot just wait 7 years and expect your debts to go away. Some won't even come off your credi report. Some creditors will sell your debt to another collector and they will report it as new so now you have two entries on your credi report for the same debt but by two diff companies. Also if the creditor marks your debt account as a current loan it will continue to show up on your report. The 7 year timer starts from the point the account was closed and marked as delinquent. All a creditor has to do is reopen, or sell the debt and the timer starts all over again. Some of my debts were 15 years old! And had no signs of going away.

Hospital debts are the least damaging and dept store credit cards are the worst!

If you make the decision to file, commit to it and stop trying to pay off the debt, instead use that money to pay for the bankruptcy and to get some secured credit cards after it is all over. Good luck! 

Are we done yet --- 14 years ago -

had an ER visit when I was 16 that went under my SSN even though I was a minor, and even though it has been well over 7 years and is no longer on my credit report that hospital will not see me (unless for an emergency, that's the law) and they can still send me mail asking for payment. 


I also had medical bills from when i was younger than that i was between 9 and 14 but it wasnt even an ER visit it was just regular dr appts. How we noticed this was i went to get a cell phone in my name and the cell phone company told me based on my credit check i needed a 6 or 800 dollar deposit. so my mom went home and pulled up a credit report on me and i had medical bills in my name its like WTF. I should have had no credit because i still lived at home not car loan no nothing!! Altho since then the medical bills have dropped off my credit and my credit is in the 600's. 

wifey9089 --- 14 years ago -

wifey you really think it takes less time? we have been working 8 years on getting his identity theft fixed. His credit score is 430 from this ! Cant get much worse then that. I apperciate everyones comments, and are taking them all into cosideration. However we are still going to talk to a lawyer. Also how long ago was it that your parents filed?


Sorry, in your initial post you said "a couple years" so I took it literally to mean 2 years.
They filed 10 yrs ago and as soon as the bankruptcy term was over they had bill collectors calling trying to get more money than they settled for. Had to take them to court, which took another year to clear up. When all was said and done, they spent more money on the bankruptcy than they would have if they had paid off their debt instead.

Your situation is really really bad, which makes me think bankruptcy won't fix it. It sounds like your best bet is to get the new SSN, because his old one will forever be stolen and can get damaged all over again. I don't know the statistics, but I know from a couple personal finance classes that your risk of a repeat stolen identity is pretty high.
My husband actually had someone who opened a credit card in his name before he was even born and it's taken a year just to get that off his credit reports. They tried giving us the whole "oh, it'll fall off" crap but I wouldn't back down, because obviously it won't fall off if it's been there for 22 years.

I'm assuming you went through all the shutting down that you could as far as preventing any more use of your husband's identity? If every single thing is flagged, then if someone tries to use it again, they will get caught red-handed. If someone gets caught, it should be easier to get all those companies to back off.

You should also consider counter-suing the companies that so freely gave out all that credit, especially the one who gave the thief a house. They should have run a much more thorough background check. Not to mention all those credit cards all at once should have been noticed by those companies as a major red flag, but they just wanted to make a profit off one more guy going into debt, so they didn't bother to look into it. 

Tee C --- 14 years ago -

This thread has been really edifying. I did not know that bankruptcy does not mean that all your debts are forgiven.

Mysoldiershot, I don't have anything to offer you in terms of bankruptcy advice, but I am very sorry that someone got a hold of your husband's social and ruined his credit in that way. I agree with wifey9089 about suing the credit card companies; they should have done a better job of checking before issuing cards under your husband's social.

Blessings to you; I know things are hard right now and I pray they all work out in your favor. 

mysoldiershot --- 14 years ago -

We really DONT want to file bankruptcy, we pay OUR bills on time monthly. But we are just so down under because of this.
On all of the credit companies equifax, experian etc, it clearly states that there is a 10 year fraud alert on his credit and they are SUPPOSE to call , verify it is my husband and he needs to fax his id over. HOWEVER we did find out whoever stole his identity has made fake id's up with all my husbands info. Just different picture. So yeah its a huge apin in the ass. And sorry wife i was just putting the quick story in the first post, i shouldnt have said a couple years thats my fault. I wasnt trying to come across as being nasty when i said it wasnt easy. 

mysoldiershot --- 14 years ago -

Thank you Tee C 

wifey9089 --- 14 years ago -

Something one of my personal finance profs said once was about identity theft: Remember it's not your debt. When the collectors call it's their job to get money from you, so they'll say anything to get you to pay, even if it's not your bill. Don't give those people a dime and when they call tell them next time they should make sure the person applying for the credit is legitimate. Don't feel like you have to pay for their screw up.
I bet there's a lawyer you could talk to who could get those calls to stop since you're a fraud victim. Like a cease and desist. JAG is overrun, understaffed and limited in what they can do. You need a specialty lawyer. 

notsue --- 14 years ago -

The key to have things go away is to ignore the new people handling them... once you ackknowledge the debt, or even make a payment, you are giving permission for it to be reported again on your report. If you just go into hiding for 7-10 years and dont communicate with anyone, you will have a clean slate. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Riley Underground