Riley Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Riley bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for sale near Fort Riley courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Children without a Country

who's talking here?

Penny Lane 4
BadLuckMommy 5
notsue 4
Tee C 2
Gemini09 4
LovinLife824 2
UGrewInMyHeart 4
JPaint21 3
Silverkitten 1
wifey9089 1
Oy vey 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Gemini09 --- 14 years ago -

What do you think about this? I think this twins should be allowed to become American citizens. I am wondering what other people think of it.

In Vitro Twins with no Country 

Penny Lane --- 14 years ago -

they are not american children. 

Silverkitten (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

What if they go through the same paperwork you would have to do if you did an adoption from over seas? Not that she needs to adopt her own kids but I mean the legal tape to make them a US citizen. 

LovinLife824 --- 14 years ago -

I agree that they aren't American. Why not just go through the paperwork and 6 months of living here?

The laws were created to prevent people from fraudulently attaining status as Americans.

People love to take advantage of the system. 

Oy vey --- 14 years ago -

They came from an American national's womb; it's an asinine, allbeit necessary, law that aught to be looked at on a case by case basis (just as in green card and citizenship issuance). 

UGrewInMyHeart --- 14 years ago -

I think they should be allowed to become American citizens. As expensive as it can be in America to adopt or go through in vitro fertilization it can be tough on some women/couples. Struggling to get pregnant and have a child is hard enough and IMO even if someone goes overseas for in vitro fertilization I think the children should still be considered American citizens, considering the parent/parents are American citizens, just like parents that go overseas to adopt. My birthdaughters parents struggled for such a long time to have a their own child and have said countless times how blessed they are to have been financially able to adopt. 

notsue --- 14 years ago -

Imagine the woman who makes a trip to France, and has a one night stand there and ends up pregnant... she comes right back to the states and finds out down the road that shes pregnant... would we question her child?
I dont think the father should matter, and I think the kids should be granted citizenship if shes coming back to her home country to raise them. 

UGrewInMyHeart --- 14 years ago -

Imagine the woman who makes a trip to France, and has a one night stand there and ends up pregnant... she comes right back to the states and finds out down the road that shes pregnant... would we question her child?
I dont think the father should matter, and I think the kids should be granted citizenship if shes coming back to her home country to raise them. 


I was thinking the EXACT thing! I'm sure that happens more often than people think and noone gives a hoot, because she was able to conceive the child herself. 

JPaint21 --- 14 years ago -

But in the "getting knocked up in France" situation, one of the biological parents is an American citizen. This woman is not the biological mother of these children. She used both donor sperm and donor eggs.

I'm not saying I agree/don't agree with the law, but I'm just saying you're not comparing apples to apples.

I still can't figure out how I feel about the law... 

notsue --- 14 years ago -

The point is that she could have done it in secret and came back here and given birth and nobody would test her baby to see if its hers or not... If you carry a child, I believe its yours and if you are a citizen then your child now should be also. 

wifey9089 --- 14 years ago -

When someone goes through in vitro in America and gives birth here, we don't generally question that the child is theirs.
There are so many different ways to get a child now, but the end result is always that the child is yours, whether legally or biologically.
I think if you carry and birth a child, it's your child, no matter the DNA. They should be considered American citizens.

Also, I think it's kind of aggravating that we spend $$ to investigate citizenship issues like this when there are so many bigger issues in immigration.

Isn't the whole point of immigration law to make sure people are paying taxes and not skirting the system? These are children...they aren't trying to skip out on taxes. 

notsue --- 14 years ago -

Exactly... 

JPaint21 --- 14 years ago -

All babies born in America are automatically citizens, regardless of their parents' citizenship status, biological or otherwise. So of course they don't question in vitro babies born here.

I am still perplexed at what weird situation would have caused this law to even come about... 

JPaint21 --- 14 years ago -

All babies born in America are automatically citizens, regardless of their parents' citizenship status, biological or otherwise. So of course they don't question in vitro babies born here.

I am still perplexed at what weird situation would have caused this law to even come about... 

Penny Lane --- 14 years ago -

something doesnt add up with this story. how can someone who lives in another country for well over three years think that her kids should be considered us citizens. if you where from another country and lived here had a child and then asked the counrty you where from 2 years later if the could be citizens do you think they would let it. no you would be considered a us citizen. 

BadLuckMommy --- 14 years ago -

Ellie Lavi, an American citizen living in Israel, wanted her children to be American as well, despite the fact that they were born in Israel

This is what makes the case. They were born in Isreal. If she wanted her children to be American then maybe she should have given birth in America! 

Gemini09 --- 14 years ago -

When a child is born to two parents who are American citizens, but they live in another country; that child is automatically an American citizen.

That is why I believe these children should become citizens without all the hassle. 

Gemini09 --- 14 years ago -

Citizenship 

BadLuckMommy --- 14 years ago -

If the Americans are not living in American and contributing to this country I don't think the right of citizenship should be given to the children. That is just my opinion, and I'm sure I catch some flack for it, but If your not paying taxes, or helping this country you don't deserve to carry the title. 

Penny Lane --- 14 years ago -

this is from the website gemini09 linked:
Birth Abroad Out-of-Wedlock to a U.S. Citizen Mother:

A person born abroad out-of-wedlock to a U.S. citizen mother may acquire U.S. citizenship under Section 309(c) of the INA if the mother was a U.S. citizen at the time of the person’s birth and if the mother was physically present in the United States or one of its outlying possessions for a continuous period of one year prior to the person’s birth. The mother must be genetically related to the person in order to transmit U.S. citizenship. 

BadLuckMommy --- 14 years ago -

The mother must be genetically related to the person in order to transmit U.S. citizenship 

BadLuckMommy --- 14 years ago -

The mother wasn't genetically related to the children therefor no citizenship.

I think the only person to be blamed is the mother for not doing her research in something that is very important. 

Gemini09 --- 14 years ago -

No, she didn't do her research.

I do think that the laws need to be updated with the times. 

BadLuckMommy --- 14 years ago -

I do think that the laws need to be updated with the times.

I agree there are plenty of cases that suffer, not just citizenship but alot of different cases due to the laws not being updated. 

Tee C --- 14 years ago -

Just my opinion: if I was going to have children under those circumstances, you'd better believe that I would have exhausted myself researching and gathering every shred of information I could get my hands on about citizenship before even thinking about stepping foot in the in-vitro clinic. It's very telling that she feels "embarrassed, humiliated, horrified", "ashamed"--when she could have prevented feeling that way by researching and weighing her options. When it comes to international law, assuming will get you into a world of headaches. 

Penny Lane --- 14 years ago -

http://adoption.state.gov/adoption_process/who_can_adopt/livingabroad.php 

LovinLife824 --- 14 years ago -

If she wanted her children to be American then maybe she should have given birth in America!

Exactly. She chooses not to live in America and it doesn't look like she plans on coming back any time soon, so why should her children get citizenship to a country she contributes nothing to and doesn't even want to live in? It seems like she just wants to get around living here for 6 months and the paperwork. 

UGrewInMyHeart --- 14 years ago -

Oops, it seems I misunderstood the story a bit. I thought she had just had her children there and moved BACK to America right after. As my husband and I were discussing it and I was reading the story again I realized it. I was like "wait a minute..." I must go back on what I previously said, considering she isn't even living in America. Obviously, if she lived here I would feel different, but how can she expect her children to be American citizens if neither of them even live here? 

Tee C --- 14 years ago -

This is what it sounds like to me:

- In-vitro fertilization costs in the ten-thousands to the hundred-thousands. Seems she wanted to to be in Israel to take advantage of the free in-vitro they offer, but she didn't properly think things through before doing so.

- She wants to retain the benefits of American citizenship for her children without following the rules. No, I am not one of those nationalist Americans who can't see past the tips of their noses so they think America is the end-all/be-all. It's just that having US citizenship for her children would guarantee her certain rights for them (such as embassy support in the event there was a crisis in Israel and she needed to get out of the country immediately).

In a nutshell, sounds like she tried to milk Israel for some free in-vitro, and now she's upset because she didn't do her research and things backfired. I don't feel sorry for her; I feel sorry for the children. 

UGrewInMyHeart --- 14 years ago -

In a nutshell, sounds like she tried to milk Israel for some free in-vitro, and now she's upset because she didn't do her research and things backfired. I don't feel sorry for her; I feel sorry for the children. 



Sounds about right to me too and I agree, I feel bad for the children...not her at all. Another example of children paying for their parent(s) mistakes :/ 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Riley Underground