Riley Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Riley bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for sale near Fort Riley courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Tax Question....Has anyone ever had this happen?

who's talking here?

Mandi 5
Carrie 1
BadLuckMommy 1
Natalie 1
Jennie 1
domestic diva 4
littamomto5 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Mandi --- 16 years ago -

I filed our taxes online today and with great relief that they were "done". Then I get a nice little email this evening from the IRS telling me that our return has been rejected because a social security number can only be used on one return and only one person can claim the same dependent. We had custody of my son's daughter for the year and it was agreed to in Court that we would be able to claim her for tax purposes. My husband's ex-wife decided she would claim her anyways this year. Now our return has been rejected. We also found out that she claimed his daughter last year for the EIC credit and she didn't even see her mom one day that year. His ex also works as a tax preparer for a reputable company so I know that it's not that she doesn't understand and did it by accident. Now we have to play the wait game until the morning to see what we need to do. Just curious if anyone has had this happen where someone claimed a child and they weren't supposed to and what happened, what did you have to do to get your taxes refiled.  

Carrie --- 16 years ago -

Your going to have to do a paper file, so they can figure out who is really suppose to claim the child. 

Mandi --- 16 years ago -

Thank you Carrie. So when we paper file, do I need to send a copy of the Court Order that states we are to claim her? The thing that makes me upset is that she NEVER does what the Court orders her to do. She thinks she can do whatever she wants and it doesn't matter what anyone including the Court tells her, if she doesn't want to do it then she doesn't. I'm just extremely aggrevated with this whole situation. Can she get into trouble with the IRS for claiming her for the EIC last year when she didn't live with her let alone even see her and then this year when she did it and was ordered yet again not to? 

littamomto5 --- 16 years ago -

You have to show proof that you had her for more than six months and show the court papers. After that is done you will get the return and she will have to pay it back. It will take a little bit longer to get your return but you will get it. We had to do this last year with my DH ex. 

Jennie --- 16 years ago -

If there is a Court order stating you are to claim her, then that needs to be sent to the IRS plus if you have the child more than 6 mons out of the year and can prove it (i.e. school records and such) they will need this too. My ex and I take turns claiming our kids. It is court ordered in our custody agreement even though I am custodial parent AND the girls stay with me pretty much the entire year as their father is a soldier too. Call the IRS about this. I did because I was told by another that I should still claim them irregardless of the order because I keep them all year round. I was told by the IRS that I am to follow the court order. The mother in this case can get in trouble if the IRS is in your favor-which it will be. Call them, explain the situation and such. They will be able to tell you the best course of action...better than any of us. I even had to call them once because my hubby's name in their system is wrong-- he has changed it over and over with them, but still it comes up wrong. The first yr I did his taxes it was shot back because of this reason. I called them then and they said just write it the wrong way because that is how it is in their system and had been for years. Here are the local IRS numbers...good luck! City Street Address Days/Hours of Service Telephone * Overland Park 6717 Shawnee Mission Parkway, Overland Park, KS 66202 Monday-Friday - 8:30 a.m.- 4:30 p.m. Services Provided (816) 966-2840 Topeka 120 S.E. Sixth Ave. Topeka, KS 66603 Monday-Friday - 8:30 a.m.- 4:30 p.m. Services Provided (785) 235-3053 Wichita 271 W. Third St. North Wichita, KS 67202 Monday-Friday - 8:30 a.m.- 4:30 p.m. Services Provided (316) 352-7401 

BadLuckMommy --- 16 years ago -

I just went through this with my step son. Needless to say the ex had to payback the IRS, and we had to show proof we had him all year along with his ssc, and birth certificate. You have to do a paperfile now. 

Natalie --- 16 years ago -

Same here, we pay an unbelievable amount of support each month and the court only gave us 35 days each year for visitation (due to moving, travel, and such), however, we also got to claim him every other year which just pissed his mother off! The IRS agent that I spoke to told me that when we claim him, just to go ahead and send a copy of the court order with the return so that if there are any questions about it, the court order will be there and the return will not be held up. So far it has worked for us. She took that stimulus check for the child but when it came time to do taxes and to report it, well, that was our year, so we got an extra $300 and she had to pay it back. Best day of my life:) 

domestic diva --- 16 years ago -

If its set in stone anywhere in the divorce papers about taxes (which it usually is) then she did something illegal. Not only that but she is suposed to notify or talk to the other parent about these kinds of decisions. On another note, you could also probably sue her. If she and your husband made a verbal agreement, that is a legal binding contract and will hold up in court and you can sue her for what you guys were suposed to get. You would go to small claims court. The IRS if you were actually able to claim the child, would be audited. If that happened, she would more than likely end up having to pay back was rigtfully yours. I personally would turn her in. Maybe even talk to IRS or go and talk to a CPA. 

Mandi --- 16 years ago -

Thank you all for you help. We do in fact have a signed Court order stating that we get to claim her this year and she gets to claim her every year after this. She lived with us for 8 1/2 months last year and her mother didn't support her at all, not even a dollar for 2 1/2 years. We found out that she claimed her last year for the EIC credit as well. I spoke with the IRS today and we have to mail in a paper return. Then in December of 2010 they will send a notice out to both of us stating that both parties claimed the same child and then we have to send in school records and a copy of the court order. They said they would pay both of us the EIC and then at the end of this year, whichever one wasn't supposed to claim her will have to pay it back. Which will be her. We have a signed copy of the order that she signed stating that we would claim her for 2009 tax year and she would claim her starting in 2010. I know she is going to come up with some excuse and play it off as she thought that it meant for the taxes she files in 2009. She is just that way. But considering we went to Court in August and agreed to that then common sense tells you that it means 2009 taxes and we specifically specified that it would be for the taxes we filed in 2010. I've already dowloaded the forms to report her the 2008 and the 2009 eic tax fraud that she committed. I hope it bars her from being able to do taxes at the place she works at each year and she can't claim the EIC for a long time. I'm sure she will be calling when she has to pay it back to want to talk to him then! Natalie-That is the sweetest revenge her having to pay it back. Love it! DD- she always makes whatever decisions she wants to, it was like that for 2 1/2 years during our Court hearings. She is still not doing everything in the Court Order that she is supposed to with their daughter. If you try to talk to her about it she just hangs up and then we don't hear from her or his daughter for about a month. She would deliberately disobey court orders and they never did anything to her. So, I believe she thinks she can do whatever she wants and nothing will happen. However, the IRS would be so lenient. 

domestic diva --- 16 years ago -

Mandi, I read what you put, and man. She really dug herself a whole. Just so you know, the ball is in your court. You will win this. Legal is legal. Straight up. She can give whatever excuse she wants to but they are going to know better because she is a tax preparer and already knows. Not only that but she signed a legal paper stating to let you guys claim her, you have proof she was with you and the court order for her to let you claim her this year. Yeah, she screwed herself for sure! People always get to cocky and when they do, thats when they mess up, just like this and she will only get what she deserves. I do not like dead beat moms. She is going to love paying that back. We claimed two kids and got well over $4000 so I can only imagine what it is for one child and not only that but sounds like you guys deserve it way more. 

Mandi --- 16 years ago -

DD- Thank you. We've always tried to keep a good relationship with her for the sake of their daughter, however, you can't even reason with her when she doesn't want to do something. It's her way and even if she's in the wrong she blames it on someone else. I hate to do this because I know it's going to put a bigger strain on my husband's and her relationship and I don't want to cause anymore tension for the sake of their daughter. However, I will not sit by and let her try to mess up our taxes and then we end up getting in trouble because we knew she did it fraudulently and didn't do anything about it. I know that it's not us that are hard to get along with because me and my husband get along very well with my ex-husband and his wife. It's because we put our daughter ahead of any issues and don't hold grudges. It's sad because it's not us that are getting hurt by the strain on the relationship it's their daughter. But she fails to see this. I just hope one day she will come to her senses before it's to late. I can only imagine how much it will be with interest, principal, and penalties for 2 years. We claimed her as a deduction on his paycheck and it made a HUGE difference not claiming her. 

domestic diva --- 16 years ago -

Mandi, I understand about the strains of it. The thing is, you do something wrong, there are consequences. No if, and's or buts. I know it sucks. I beleive you when you say that you try to get along with her for the sake of her daughter. I feel for you. It will be hard because of what she may try do but you must be strong. Don't let someone like that walk all over you. My husband and I deal with the same crap from his ex-wife. We have always tried to get along for the sake of his two boys but she always tries to start drama, be scandelous or try to screw us over. She even went as so far as to get her children to turn agianst us but what she doesn't realize is that her children aren't as dumb as she thought. There's always some kind of issue or fight. I think you and I have a lot in common. Not even kidding. I totally understand everything your going thru. 

Mandi --- 16 years ago -

DD- I completely agree. Being deceptive and intentionally doing something you know is wrong is just that, WRONG. She has tried turning his daughter against all of us as well as his parents. She sneaks around to call us and email us because she doesn't want to make her mom mad. But the calls and emails have almost came to a complete halt now. She has a very strong hold on her now. She is 12 years old and doesn't even sleep in her own bed anymore, she sleeps with her mom. She had told us when she lived with us that her mom hated us and told us all these negative things about us to her. So, I know that she is still doing that. They live so far away and everytime that he has supposed to have had her since the hearing she has intentionally made it impossible for us to take her. His parents live 2 hours from her and they get her 1 weekend a month and they have gotten her 1 full weekend since August. She always has an excuse or just doesn't return their calls or answer her phone. She is supposed to have their daughter in counseling as well, per the court order, she still hasn't done that. I do think we have alot in common as well. It's sad to see that there are mothers like this out there. I couldn't imagine putting my child through this to have to pick and choose one parent over the other. When it's quiet and we don't hear anything from his ex, I'm always wondering what is it that she will be hitting us with next. It never fails. 

domestic diva --- 16 years ago -

Man. Thats horrible. She sounds extreamly immature. Some people are just not good enough to be parents. I'm not even kidding. You should always put your feelings asside for the kids. I always do. Trust me, there have been times where I wanted to go off and fight with their mother but know I can't because of what it would do to them. Even when they knew she deserves it. I am so sorry that you have to go thru this. Its never easy and that fact she is basically holding her hostage is a very evil thing to do. We too have had our up and downs like that too. Well, more at the begining but now its just all kinds of other drama. Have you reported her to the courts? Letting them know she has violated the court orders? I would keep pushing it as much as you can. It can be overwelming and physically draing but you just have to keep letting her know you won't back down. Let the courts knw that she talks about you guys too. That is actually frowned upon in the courts eyes. I have researched it. It could cause her to lose custody. The child is alos 12? She can legally chose who she wants to live with as well. All she has to do is tell them all that stuff and you guys could easily get custody. We go thru a lot too. Normally when we talk to the ex, its some kind of BS but we just try to deal with it. However, ever since I have been putting my two cents in, she is kind of backing off on a few things. Guess she thought I was a push over. She thought wrong on that. Glad my man finally started to let me say what I got to say. Seems to do some good because I am not a force to recond with. I tell it like it is. We too have delt with so much from her. Its rediculous how some people act. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
help

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Riley Underground