Riley Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Riley bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for sale near Fort Riley courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Follow-Up On Breastfeeding Soldiers' Story

who's talking here?

Penny Lane 4
Hope 1
notsue 1
Tee C 3
toriT 1
Cookie 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Tee C --- 14 years ago -

Cookie mentioned that she reads the Stars & Stripes, so I went to their website to check it out since it has been so long since I've read it. Well, it turns out that the two soldiers photographed while breastfeeding in uniform weren't supposed to after all:

http://www.stripes.com/news/military-moms-in-breast-feeding-photos-say-they-ve-been-silenced-by-superiors-1.179249

They weren't disciplined because they were breastfeeding in uniform; they were disciplined because they didn't properly go through their Public Affairs Office for clearance to be photographed while in uniform for a private cause. 

Cookie --- 14 years ago -

I think nursing/lactating rooms should be provided throughout communities just like restrooms to squash this whole nursing in public debate. Remember when changing tables never existed in public restrooms? Now they are located throught many women's and men's public restrooms throught the country. I figure it's a part of life: adapt. 

toriT --- 14 years ago -

I guess I'm too young to ever remember NOT having changing tables in bathrooms. Not something I ever thought about.
I don't think Nursing Rooms would stop the debate though (although I think they'd be helpful just as a quiet place to take ANY child!) because people will still say the "If my breastfed baby has to eat in a separate room why doesn't a bottle-fed baby?" line. 

Penny Lane --- 14 years ago -

I figure it's a part of life: adapt.

so one side of the view is if you dont want to see someone bf they should be banished to a closet because it is gross, but that persons right to do some thing that is protected by law should just be able to look at you and say ADAPT!

what do you think they did 125 years ago? everyone breastfed and if a woman couldnt then they had wet nurses. i am sure it was done whenever wherever however. then 100 years ago a doctor could perscribe the mother who couldn't BF a "formula" perscription.

in the late 80's you could go to the store and buy it.

what about the national geographic magizines i remember seeing as a kid with thrid world country women on the cover with a basket on there head full and the baby in a sling across thier chest BF. 

Penny Lane --- 14 years ago -

United States

In the United States, infant formula is both heavily marketed – the country has not adopted the Code, nor is it being systematically implemented by manufacturers for domestic marketing[96] – and even heavily subsidized by the government: at least one third of the American market is supported by the government,[29] with over half of infant formula sold in the country provided through the Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants and Children (known as WIC).[47]

According to surveys, over 70% of large U.S. hospitals dispense infant formula to all infants, a practice opposed by the American Academy of Pediatrics and in violation of the Code.[97] The Gerber Products Company began marketing its brand of infant formula directly to the public in October 1989, while the Carnation Company began marketing Good Start infant formula directly to the public in January 1991.[97]

Infant formula costs are a significant fraction of the WIC program costs: 21% post-rebate and 46% pre-rebate.[47] Formula manufacturers are granted a WIC monopoly in individual states.[47] Meanwhile breastfeeding rates are substantially lower for WIC recipients;[76] this is partly attributed to formula being free of charge to mothers in the WIC program, who are of lower socio-economic status.[47] Violations of federal policy have also been found in terms of infant formula company advertising using the WIC trademark, to reach both WIC and non-WIC participants.[76] In recent years WIC has been expanding its breastfeeding promotion strategies, including providing subsidies for clients who use milk banks.[98]


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Infant_formula 

Cookie --- 14 years ago -

Not particularly sure why you are going off on a tangent. I breast fed all three of my children till they were a year old; I rather enjoyed the comfortable lactating rooms I encountered in my town and while I traveled. I'm modest, boo-hoo. Once outhouses were the thing; I'm glad we've "adapted" toward indoor plumbing and private stalled restrooms (many countries don't even offer that).

Who said breast feeding is gross? Don't bother going off on bottle fed infants not having to be covered via a blanket, because it is a fallacious argument you can't win.

Wet nurses are still around today, lol.

I see discreet women nursing in public all the time; doesn't bother me in the slightest. Why? Because they are being discreet and not advertising their business to the world. 

Cookie --- 14 years ago -

I figure it's a part of life: adapt.

I was referring to companies/businesses/shopping centers adapting and providing lactation rooms. They are all over outlet malls and other shops where I am from. They are not dingy rooms women are shuttled off to, to do this hideous thing called nursing (sarcasm); or, gasp, pumping breast milk. 

Penny Lane --- 14 years ago -

why can a few number of people( who think women should BF in a private place or the baby covered)take the rights away from a woman who wants to BF at a booth in applebee's because she wants to eat her food too.

if you BF you baby in public under
a blanket that is your right. but if i want (and i did) BF my baby in a public place uncovered that is my right that noone can take away. actually it is protected by law. i can not go to jail unless i overexpose myself by walking around the place with and breast hanging out and a baby nowhere in sight. 

Penny Lane --- 14 years ago -

I was referring to companies/businesses/shopping centers adapting and providing lactation rooms. They are all over outlet malls and other shops where I am from. They are not dingy rooms women are shuttled off to, to do this hideous thing called nursing (sarcasm); or, gasp, pumping breast milk.

oh ok i took it as everyone should adapt to the view of some. 

Tee C --- 14 years ago -

I was referring to companies/businesses/shopping centers adapting and providing lactation rooms. They are all over outlet malls and other shops where I am from. They are not dingy rooms women are shuttled off to, to do this hideous thing called nursing (sarcasm); or, gasp, pumping breast milk. 

I knew what you were getting at, lol. Some 'hot button' issues just cause certain reactions in some people. Besides, the other thread was about the breastfeeding debate; this thread was about the soldiers in question being reprimanded for having their pictures taken while in uniform for a personal cause without getting permission from Public Affairs first. Breastfeeding or not, they weren't supposed to do that. But many people turned it into a breastfeeding issue; it wasn't. If they had an anal commander they could have faced a hefty reprimand. We had a soldier in Texas lose 2 ranks because he went to a fundraising rally for President Bush while in uniform. Duh. You can support whomever you want for President, but you can't do it wearing your greens, genius. 

notsue --- 14 years ago -

Nice read. 

Tee C --- 14 years ago -

woman breastfeeding was on the clock when she left to do media coverage/photos fired misuse of employers 

Breastfeeding issues or no--she is not that bright. Standing up for a cause is one thing; doing it in uniform and being a thief by stealing company time and resources are two completely different issues. Hey genius--if you're going to play hookey from work to go take pictures, at least have enough sense not to use the company vehicle to do it. Oh, and don't submit a time card so you'll get paid for doing it, too. Wow. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Riley Underground