Riley Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Riley bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for sale near Fort Riley courtesy of Remilitary.com!

killings in Afgan.

who's talking here?

Tee C 3
Gemini09 1
AMRYWIFE25 3
UGrewInMyHeart 6
MrsG2007 1
a3787367uu 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

AMRYWIFE25 --- 14 years ago -

http://news.yahoo.com/afghans-us-paid-50k-per-shooting-spree-death-160404824.html

Wheres the money for the people killed in 9-11? Why doesn't Afgan and Iraq pay our families? 

UGrewInMyHeart --- 14 years ago -

The innocent people that were killed were not the ones responsible for 9/11. They were just as innocent as the ones that passed in the acts of 9/11. No amount of money could bring any of those innocent people that have been killed (9/11 or the recent attack committed by a soldier). What did the U.S. do when our country was attacked on 9/11 and innocent people were killed? Hmm...
If we were to compare / treat that to this recent attack the person responsible would end up like...well you know who
IMO that's why it's a bit difficult to compare the United States to Afghanistan and/or Iraq. Also, IMO there's no justification for our country being attacked on 9/11 OR the recent attacks of innocent people in Afghanistan. No matter the reason, innocent people are exactly that, innocent, and the criminals should be punished just like any other crime. 

Tee C --- 14 years ago -

Just as the United States is not responsible for terrorists who happen to be American, Afghan civilians who do not participate in terrorism are not responsible when their country's brethern decide to fly planes into buildings in the name of terrorism. Timothy McVeigh was an American, and I am too--but I am not responsible for what he choose to do simply by nature of being citizens of the same country.

When I travel abroad and people find out I'm American, I get a flack about being a warmonger--just because I'm American. Guilt by association.

In my opinion, that soldier acted like a coward. If I get beaten up by adults, should I go into a daycare center and beat up the children there? No; I should take my anger out on the people who wronged me. If he was really bada*s he should have walked into an enemy camp and opened fire. 

UGrewInMyHeart --- 14 years ago -

If he was really bada*s he should have walked into an enemy camp and opened fire. 

EXACTLY!!

My husband works with someone who also works in intelligence and we hang out with him and his wife often. He told me the back story as to "why" he (likely was) upset, because of something that happened to some of our people there recently. We all were discussing it and even stated something similar to what you said; if he wanted to "prove some sort of point" he could have (in all actuality shouldn't have, but just saying) went and killed people within the groups that they are there helping the afghan soldiers fight against. To kill INNOCENT people was no way to go about it. Military or not, murder is murder. Just because a group of people attack America, doesn't give an American a right to attack their innocent people. Yes, MAYBE...he did have some mental issues and just snapped, BUT THAT IS NO EXCUSE. Something else we discussed: OBVIOUSLY he does have some sort of mental issue(s), BUT what murder doesn't? For someone to be able to go and murder someone or over a dozen people there has to be something wrong with them. Just because they're victims were not American does not and should not affect the murderers punishment. All I see is people blaming the government, the military, the murderers leaders, etc and giving this guy sympathy...IMO it's a load of BS! How can some people blame everyone else EXCEPT the "good guy", "hero", "a guy that just snapped"...NO, the guy that walked into peoples homes and killed innocent men, women, and children. I'm not saying the guy hasn't done a lot for our country, but to cut this guy slack for it, is what I don't agree with. To compare what this guy did to 9/11 and see people say things like "who cares, they killed our innocent people" makes me sick. We (obviously) go to war with groups of people of attack our country, so how is this guy actions any different than that of a terrorists actions? Yes, I know, he has been through several deployments, but that shouldn't affect his punishment. He attacked innocent Afghanistan citizens just as a group of people did to American citizens. 

AMRYWIFE25 --- 14 years ago -

In my opinion, that soldier acted like a coward. If I get beaten up by adults, should I go into a daycare center and beat up the children there? No; I should take my anger out on the people who wronged me. If he was really bada*s he should have walked into an enemy camp and opened fire.

lol true but we don't know what happened the news has changed the stories mult. times.. I'm not saying it to be mean but we are cutting troops for money purposes and paying 50k for each person over there.. I'm not trying to be mean or rude but that could help our soldiers and our citizens. 50k x 17.. alot of money that could help our country just saying 

Tee C --- 14 years ago -

To compare what this guy did to 9/11 and see people say things like "who cares, they killed our innocent people" makes me sick.

And me as well. But it's indicative of the mindset of the world we live in today. I'm still trying to understand how someone can justify a person killing a group of people who did nothing to him. Can you imagine if we all went around killing everyone who looked like someone who had done us wrong? We'd all be dead. 

Tee C --- 14 years ago -

lol true but we don't know what happened the news has changed the stories mult. times.. I'm not saying it to be mean but we are cutting troops for money purposes and paying 50k for each person over there.. I'm not trying to be mean or rude but that could help our soldiers and our citizens. 50k x 17.. alot of money that could help our country just saying 

I understand the intent of what you're saying, but I think you're comparing apples to oranges.

We elect a government who spends $600 on toilet seats, and an average of $12,000 a week on lunch for 2 congressman--and all on the American taxpayer's dime. We put these same people back into office year after year with no outrage over how they spend our money, even when they don't do their jobs and threaten to shut the government down )so our spouses don't get paid). After all that, we get upset about $850,000 dollars paid to the families of Afghan citizens whom an American soldier killed or maimed. How? In the grand scheme of things, why are we angry about "our" money going to those victims, but we don't take our own representatives to task on the poor spending they exhibit on a daily basis.

I can tell you why: it's because that money has nothing to do with whether our country can afford it. I am not saying you fall under this statement, but a lot of Americans are angry those Afghan families are getting the money because they are still holding on to being narrow-minded and xenophobic against people from the Middle East because of 9/11; it has nothing to do with the money itself. They are the same people that still glare at Arabic women who wear hijabs, or men of middle-eastern descent who walk past them in the streets wearing burkas or turbans.

I wonder how those same people would feel about being paid $50,000 if their loved one was slaughtered in their sleep. Somehow I think the tables would turn--because in America we sue for being burned by a cup of coffee, so I don't think $50,000 wouldn't be nearly enough. 

AMRYWIFE25 --- 14 years ago -

"
We elect a government who spends $600 on toilet seats, and an average of $12,000 a week on lunch for 2 congressman--and all on the American taxpayer's dime. We put these same people back into office year after year with no outrage over how they spend our money, even when they don't do their jobs and threaten to shut the government down )so our spouses don't get paid). After all that, we get upset about $850,000 dollars paid to the families of Afghan citizens whom an American soldier killed or maimed. How? In the grand scheme of things, why are we angry about "our" money going to those victims, but we don't take our own representatives to task on the poor spending they exhibit on a daily basis."


im more mad that we don't know what happened. There's a victim that has a different story and there mult. stories going around. I don't think we should have to pay until they absolutely know what happened. I'm just trying to say we should have the right to know exactly what happened before our tax money goes to them. There are just to many questions and different stories for me to believe it. Plus there's a victim that has a different story, no evidence, and now there saying he went off post twice and somehow got back on. I just don't understand how he could walk off and on post with no one stopping him? 

UGrewInMyHeart --- 14 years ago -

im more mad that we don't know what happened. There's a victim that has a different story and there mult. stories going around. I don't think we should have to pay until they absolutely know what happened. I'm just trying to say we should have the right to know exactly what happened before our tax money goes to them. There are just to many questions and different stories for me to believe it. Plus there's a victim that has a different story, no evidence, and now there saying he went off post twice and somehow got back on. I just don't understand how he could walk off and on post with no one stopping him?

There must be enough evidence for him to be charged with 17 counts of murder. No, the media doesn't seem to always give out all the details, but in this case the basic facts have been released.

I'm not saying it to be mean but we are cutting troops for money purposes and paying 50k for each person over there..

The "war" is drawing down soon and the military doesn't need as many people as they have now. There has to be cuts somewhere...The part I don't get is how they can still pay $24million for just ONE base commissary and they continue to build/renovate more of them. To me that's a complete waste of money. It's a grocery store, woohoo it looks nice...I still say that money could have went elsewhere where it was needed ;)

And me as well. But it's indicative of the mindset of the world we live in today. I'm still trying to understand how someone can justify a person killing a group of people who did nothing to him. Can you imagine if we all went around killing everyone who looked like someone who had done us wrong? We'd all be dead.

Exactly, oh yeah their country attacked ours so I'll take it upon myself to attack their innocent people...bad idea 

UGrewInMyHeart --- 14 years ago -

Americans are angry those Afghan families are getting the money because they are still holding on to being narrow-minded and xenophobic against people from the Middle East because of 9/11; it has nothing to do with the money itself. They are the same people that still glare at Arabic women who wear hijabs, or men of middle-eastern descent who walk past them in the streets wearing burkas or turbans.

Yep, sad that people are still like that. Not everyone from a ethnic background is the exact same, if only more people would open their eyes and realize that. Although I've found it's usually people that already have some sort of hatred towards certain people...(sometimes that is). 

Gemini09 --- 14 years ago -

A US soldier walked around and killed all those people therefore the US is liable for it. He was sent there on orders from the US to represent our country, and used US equipment to get kill all those people.

If it were some random US citizen who had been living there among them a while then things may have played out differently.

It is pretty cut and dry if you ask me.

You can't ignore your responsibility to someone just because you can't afford the money to pay. 

a3787367uu --- 14 years ago -

Wheres the money for the people killed in 9-11? Why doesn't Afgan and Iraq pay our families?

Eleven days after the attacks claimed more than 2,700 lives, Congress created a $7 billion fund to compensate 5,562 family members of the fallen. Payments went to widows and widowers, children and parents. The payment for death claims averaged $2,083,000 for families, while compensation for injury claims averaged $400,000.Try looking stuff up before you talk crap about it. 

UGrewInMyHeart --- 14 years ago -

Try looking stuff up before you talk crap about it. 

*like!! 

MrsG2007 --- 14 years ago -

Try looking stuff up before you talk crap about it.
I think the point that the original poster (sorry if that's not the correct terminology, I'm still pretty new at this) was trying to make is that neither Afghanistan or Iraq contributed financially to the victims of 9-11 and their families. As you stated, Congress established that fund, therefore making it "American" monies that were paid out/set aside. Perhaps I am not fully informed (which is entirely possible, quite frankly) and maybe Congress worked out some sort of financial agreement with the two countries in question in which they would make payments to support the fund over time, etc, but as of right now, it looks like the American government gets the credit. I'm just glad to live in a country that realizes the wrongs that have been committed and is working to relieve the financial burders of these Afghan families. I know I'd appreciate the gesture if I were in their shoes. 

UGrewInMyHeart --- 14 years ago -

was trying to make is that neither Afghanistan or Iraq contributed financially to the victims of 9-11 and their families.

That's true. Not trying to be rude to the OP, but we're ARE talking about Afghanistan / Iraq here. Where would they get any money for that?? Their technically a third world country and that is why we're there (to help...). It doesn't matter if people agree with us helping other countries or not; America has almost always done so, so I don't see it changing anytime soon.
Maybe the OP was just blowing off some steam, but either way it's best to look at the whole picture of things.
I know it's a touchy subject, but if a military spouse passes away (w/ the exception of a couple causes) there's life insurance and the spouse receives money to be able to take care of his / her family. That's how I look at this in a way, because what if some of the victims are the head of their household. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Riley Underground