So apparently my husbands troop is doing some Dine in thing at the VFW in Manhattan...has been said that if they don't go to the actual dine in, they have to go there in ACU'S and clean..last I knew they couldn't make anything "mandatory" that served alcohol but whatever, seems this unit does a lot that isn't supposed to happen. Either way rather than him be gone and cleaning, I guess we're paying the sitter, paying the 20 dollars to go, paying for a dress (i guess thats what I have to wear, never even heard of one of these but he has to be in class a's) and pay for all the other crap that goes with all of it. I guess I'm just wondering what it is? If anybody else has ever heard of this? I really don't want to go, I don't even own a dress besides my wedding dress, or shoes or anything like that so more stuff to pay for just to spend a friday night with my husband. Anybody have any idea what this even is?
Id wear my wedding gown and tell them, unless you want to pay for my dress then this is what Im wearing lol But a dine in is a formal dinner for a unit and basically a "get to know each other" evening
I don't know. The Army is always doing dumb stuff like this. They demand you to do something outside of work and totally unrelated to military stuff. I don't like it when they do this either. I mean, I'm all for a good cause but if it's going to cost money that you really don't have and they demand you to go like you're made out of money, I don't agree with that at all. It should be voluntary, or they should pay your way to do their wishes. Anyway, good luck hon. What size are you? I have a couple dresses I'd be willing to lend to help you out.
I've actually thought about wearing my wedding dress lol. I don't have any other dress, don't have shoes, kids have stuff that night so have to figure out what to do with them, theres no day care available, it's all just ridiculous. I'm a 16, have found a few on craigslist but not really set on buying one until I know that there's no way to get out of it lol. I just have no desire to go to these things and we're PCS'ing soon. I've met the people I want to meet and hang out with them already lol. If anybody has one that'd be awesome but am still actually considering the wedding dress lol.
I'm really not even sure if I could wear that or not. We're looking for a way out of it, neither of us really want to go or try to juggle what to do with the kids that night and how to get kids here and there, they have practices that night and stuff like that. Not even sure who to ask about whatever "dress code". Thanks!
Definitely have him check to see if spouses are supposed to/allowed to come. A dine in is different than a ball, from what I remember. Prior to the hubby's deployment, there was an event that only the soldiers got to attend; they had to dress in Class As/dress blues, so it was definitely somewhat formal. I just googled it and found that the unit can add in a "dine out" to the event, which is a formal dinner that spouses/guests can attend, but the actual dine in is supposed to be soldiers only. Can't hurt to have him ask!
Dining in is actually a super old tradition, and it doesn't happen very often anymore. It's considered a formal event, and typically spouses are not invited. Dining out is usually what it's called if spouses come, too.
If I was you, I would NOT wear dress pants. This is about as formal as military events get. You can usually get nice dresses second hand though, or you can often find them on clearance at the department stores, too.
Also remember, just because it is mandatory for him does NOT mean that you have to go. If it is a hardship for you financially or for your children, he won't get punished if you don't go.
Dine in's used to be only for the Soldiers, but spouses are now allowed to go. I have been to one before. And yes it is formal and we spouses were given a "class" on how to address the higher ranks, the way we shook hands, which hand to use, the way to act , talk what pieces of silverware to eat with, when to toast etc. Basically it was an etiquette class.
No it's not mandatory for me, but if he and I don't go together, he has to go in ACU'S and clean up. So in order for me to spend time with him that night, I have to go because he's gotta go either way. It's not a finance thing, its the fact that I don't own a dress or shoes or anything else that goes with it, so its all of that to buy, plus the money to go, plus figuring out what to do with the kids. I'll go buy one from craigslist or in reality I might just dye my wedding dress. It seems ridiculous to me and we're looking for a way out of it lol.
My husband says that they can't require him to stay and clean up just because you do not go with him. So you may want to have him look into that if possible at all.
As for the dress, if you can find a decent consignment store somewhere, maybe in Manhattan or something, sometimes they have pretty decent stuff as far as formal dresses go. People rarely wear them more than once or twice. But my DH says a big fat NO NO NO to wearing dress pants to a dining in, lol. It's supposed to be super formal.
I'm giggling thinking about dying my wedding dress and wearing it to an army event, but only b/c I had a HUGE dress with a cathedral length train, lol!
lol i had a pretty simple dress but im not dying it, i don't think they can do that because they're serving alcohol. if we aren't going together then he's going to do the acu thing, but I think at this point we'll just pay the 20 dollars and we'll leave, there hasn't been any requirement as for how long we have to stay, but im thinking theres a way out of it lol, there just has to be with our situation. will try consignment shops if its something we have to do, hadn't thought about those. Thanks!
Ok so maybe it's just me but I was always under the impression that they could not make it mandatory it you have to pay to attend. If I were you I might make a phone call to jag and/or IG to ask the simple question, "can they make it mandatory if you have to pay to attend?" And of course if the answer I received was no they can't I would also say then why did my husband's command in unit XYZ tell him we have to pay and we have to attend or he has to do clean up. Luckily I have never had to deal with a situation like this but it might be worth a phone call.
The mandatory part they're saying, is that they attend. If they don't pay and come in class a's, then they go in acu's and clean up. Their place of duty on a friday night is in Manhattan, which I don't think they can do since there's alcohol there but again, this unit does a whole lot they aren't supposed to do. apparently a 1sgt told them the guys under 21 would be allowed to drink too, so just another example of them doing whatever they want not really caring about regulations or rules. so glad we're leaving soon
Hey gurlmech, I have a red halter top knee length dress thatis a size 16. I could let you borrow, or sell it to you for like $40. I bought it for my sis-in-laws wedding that was a week after I had my daughter.
1sgt told them guys under 21 can drink?? IF that's TRUE it seriously has to be a "test" (to see who's dumb enough to do it), if not they're just ready to hand out article 15's.
I think you should call IG and just ask them about the unit's right to do this kind of thing. They should be able to explain it to you, and if there is no right for them to do some of these things, then IG needs to know. It's their job to monitor that stuff.
Thanks kylespunk, I found one yesterday on craigslist if I go I'll wear it and if I don't, then I have one if we ever decide to go to a ball lol. Yep the guys under 21 were told they were allowed to drink, no clue if its a test or what it is but they do stuff like this all the time. Mandatory fun days see 18 year olds shotgunning beers and stuff like that, just glad we're leaving. Have considered calling IG but since its a troop level thing I'm guessing people will know it was me and give my husband a hard time about it, seems pointless since we're leaving soon
well whoever set it up for that and the person they get to serve those drinks ..i hope they are ok with risking fines and their job for serving to the underage when they get caught
Some grog bowl? who knows we don't go to these things, not really our thing. we're the people the bbq with friends in the back yard and drink at home or go out dancing and drink some, but that's what its supposed to be, i have no idea what's going on with it, at this point i think we're paying the money to go and leaving 10 minutes later
I highly doubt you will be allowed to leave that soon. Typically at formal Army events, no one leaves until the guests of honor (highest ranks) leave. There will probably be a dinner and a program of some type and you'll be expected to sit through all of it. My guess is there may even be assigned seats and it would be fairly obvious if you aren't in yours.
I talked to the commander about it about an hour ago and told him all the issues about it, and told him I had every intention of leaving after a few minutes and nobody has said anything about how long we were "required" to stay. I've got a really smart mouth and really am to the point where I no longer even care. I asked him if he planned to hold me "against my will" otherwise known as kidnapping. I'm generally not like that but there are tons of things that just aren't right about the whole situation, will call IG on monday because even more stuff came out that they're trying to do. So will call IG and even call the VFW and ask them about minors drinking there and what would and will happen. Thanks for letting me vent!
That does seem like kidnapping lol. Hopefully you can get out of it. I would call IG if I were you just to let it be known, but again if you're leaving soon I get that point as well.
LOL I don't have to go, someone told me it was for spouses too then someone told me it wasn't and I don't even care...it wasn't my husbands commander so I said whatever I wanted to say, he's just a friend that I've known for a long time. Is all just irritating...the whole unit is a joke. No idea if the under 21 thing was a test or what, just what some of the FRG leaders were saying. No point in calling IG because I really don't care that much, we're gone soon and there are a few people from the unit he likes and that we hang out with, but other than that, it's not that important was just venting lol
No idea if the under 21 thing was a test or what, just what some of the FRG leaders were saying.
LOL!! No offense, but in my experience, you can barely every pay attention to half the stuff that comes out of their mouth. THIS IS MY OPINION AND FROM MY EXPERIENCE - for whoever wants to get mad ;) I don't feel they have the right to speak of anything that ISN'T FACT OR GIVEN TO THEM IN AN OFFICIAL letter, etc and to pass it along to others (spouses, family, etc). I'm sure some of you have ran into this, if not then lucky you :) lol
Same troop my husband is in I just found out last night. He paid 40 dollars, 20 to play paintball that day so he wasnt stuck at troop doing stupid details, and then 20 for the dinner that he was told the same exact thing. If he didn't go he'd have to be there in acu's cleaning. He figured he'd be done sooner if he just went. And under 21 would be allowed to drink. NCO'S are supposed to bring bottles and open them up into the bowl, I have a HUGE issue with my husband providing alcohol to under 21. So not just the FRG women saying that. Have heard people are upset about it but not sure if anybody has done anything about it. We hate this unit/troop. The frg is a joke, my husband, and I, have been in many different units and duty stations and this unit is by far the biggest joke we have ever seen, and that our friends have ever heard of when we tell them some of the things that go on. It's been put out that the guys under 21 will be able to drink and that alone just blows my mind, and this dinner itself being mandatory, whether it's for the dinner, or cleaning. They can't make anything mandatory that serves alcohol but they have plenty of times. And I'm with the other woman on here posting, have seen under 21 drinking at "mandatory fun days". There are quite a few women that "don't allow" their husbands to go anywhere without them or without calling them 20 times while they are gone, so I wonder how well this is all going over with them.
"Don't allow"... sad/funny all-in-one. Suspicious about a supposed, "mandatory", Veterans of Foreign Wars event? Hire a PI...(chuckling...)! JK. How do these same "women" handle deployments and TDYs?