Riley Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Riley bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for sale near Fort Riley courtesy of Remilitary.com!

BAH discussion

who's talking here?

notsue 4
Tee C 1
Gemini09 1
lovemyhubby 1
UGrewInMyHeart 7
Addie 1
JPaint21 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

notsue --- 15 years ago -

In order to not go off topic in the other thread, I wanted to put this here...

If we were not paid BAH, do you think anyone would be in the military? Dodging bullets for peanuts?

I think the confusion with our "free" money is the fact that we work for the government and they have a different way of doing things. They are not your usual company whos making a profit and just gives you a salary. The government has to budget everything and in part our checks are split up into pieces and those pieces are given different names. Its by assigning these titles for the different pays that allows them to give it to us. So its best for the ones who seem to be confused by everything to just look at the bottom line... Your husband, or yourself is paid x amount for the work they do in the military, and do no focus on splitting it up into BAH, BAS, Basic Pay and whatever else you are receiving. Because as most of us remember, in the civi world we'd get paid to do a similar job, minus the fun times overseas dodging rockets and whatnot. But in the civi world the pay would be more than what our little guys in the military get. Some of that may be because in the civi world that job would not be available to you right out of high school as it is in the military, either way, be happy you get anything, or get out. 

UGrewInMyHeart --- 15 years ago -

Like I stated in my post, It is part of a service member's pay, NOT free money. I, as well as others, I'm sure are appreciative with the fact that we receive BAH (and BAS). IMO It would be hard to afford a roof over your head if it wasn't for the pay (BAH), considering rent / homes are so much more expensive around military installations. As with a civilian job (say with a college degree) you'll get paid about the same (or more rather) than a military service member gets paid (that's WITH THEIR BAH/BAS). 

UGrewInMyHeart --- 15 years ago -

I'm thrown off by how the post I made turned into a BAH topic?? I guess some people just love to run their mouth, while having no clue what they're talking about and sounding completely illiterate ;-) 

lovemyhubby --- 15 years ago -

i 100% agree :) 

UGrewInMyHeart --- 15 years ago -

i 100% agree :)
me too ! :) 

notsue --- 15 years ago -

I just get tired of hearing about it all the time. Like how blessed that we are to receive BAH and whatnot... I'm sorry, but if we didnt receive BAH, and my husband only made the 1729 or whatever it is hes getting right now and never got to be home, and had to deal with nightly rocket attacks and whatever other nonsense, we wouldnt be in the military. Not saying that the 1023 or whatever makes all the difference, but sure does help. We dont look at it as two seperate things, we look at that total for the month and go from that. Naturally thats still a lot less monthly than what we are used to, but you figure in the warm fuzzy feeling you get for serving your country and the fact that I pay nothing for health insurance, and it makes things a lil sweeter. This is no cush job, and surely isnt for everyone. You do not join the military to get rich. 

Addie --- 15 years ago -

I am VERY thankful that we receive BAH and BAS! If we did not receive that money my family would probably be living on the streets somewhere starving. (Ok not literally, but we would not be able to afford the nice things we have such as a house, lights water gas, food , things for the new baby , a car each, etc) (as I am not working right now and am a student, who is about to be a stay at home mom in Korea.)

Be thankful for what you get and don't complain geez. 

UGrewInMyHeart --- 15 years ago -

Couldn't agree with you more notsue!! 

UGrewInMyHeart --- 15 years ago -

Addie: We'd be in the same boat and if it wasn't for the allowance we do receive there's now way we (or probably a lot of others) could afford to live anywhere close to their work (military post). I am very thankful and I feel people have the right to complain when it comes to their living conditions. Military or Civilian, no matter your situation or the amount of money you make, people still want to be comfortable where they're living. 

JPaint21 --- 15 years ago -

The reason we get allowances instead of all the money as a base pay amount is because BAH is adjusted based on where you live and base pay stays the same. It's also beneficial for the government to keep it separate because we don't pay taxes on it that way. When they do the comparisons to see if military pay is equivalent to civilian pay, they consider tax liability also.

If you were a civilian doing the same job, you might get paid a little more total (compared to base+allowances for military), but you're also going to pay a lot more in taxes because your whole income is taxed, not just part of it.

In the other thread, someone was saying that as a civilian they wouldn't get enough money because they wouldn't get BAH. Well you have to compare it to a similar job. Even in the civilian world a doctor gets paid more than a janitor, so you can't compare apples to oranges.

We looked it up one time, and my husband's job in the civilian world pays a base wage of about the same as what our base+allowances is. So they basically do get paid BAH, it's just not sorted out separately and they have to pay taxes on it.

I don't look at BAH as a separate part of our paycheck. Obviously when we move from one place to another I consider the change in BAH when looking for housing because you have to work with what the market is at. But it's not just "housing money". We can still choose to spend it as we please, and it's up to us whether we spend it on housing or not. 

Gemini09 --- 15 years ago -

Exactly JPaint! 

notsue --- 15 years ago -

Civi jobs dont pay the same in different areas either. An EMT working in San Fran will get paid different than one working in Houston. 

Tee C --- 15 years ago -

I already posted in the other thread but I will reiterate: Uncle Sugar doesn't give up a freakin' thing for "free". The housing allowance, the medical benefits, the combat pay--the American soldier earns every one of those things three times over. "Free" has nothing to do with it, and anyone who thinks so is sorely misinformed. 

notsue --- 15 years ago -

Well any civi who thinks their job compares to that of a soldier needs to be given a one-way ticket to Iraq. 

UGrewInMyHeart --- 15 years ago -

Well any civi who thinks their job compares to that of a soldier needs to be given a one-way ticket to Iraq.

♥^^^^ 

UGrewInMyHeart --- 15 years ago -

I guess Missknowitall that made the point that military service members are "given FREE moo-lah" didn't have much else to say on the issue, besides to dog me for "complaining" about our "free money" hahahaha

Like someone else said (or more than one person said, rather), civi jobs (as military BAH) pay varies depending on your location. Like I stated in my other post, I want to be a teacher. If I was to stay in Kansas my avg. (starting) salary would be approx $27,840. Say I was to live in Connecticut my avg. (starting) salary would be approx $39,259 or somewhere fairly close like Colorado $35,086. That's quite a big difference, wouldn't you say?? I believe I stated something like this on my other post; the avg salary of even a highly known low paid careers such as a teacher still earns the same / more than a military service member and that's INCLUDING his/her BAH allowance/part of pay! My husband for example (an E-4) gross a year is approx (estimating here lol) $40,000 (that's including BAH and BAS). As a FIRST YEAR teacher (one of the lowest paid salaries) you can make approx the same amount! Yes, teaching requires a degree and the military doesn't, but they put their lives on the line for not that much pay; for someone to say they are given "free money" is a disgrace!! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Riley Underground