Riley Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Riley bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for sale near Fort Riley courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Advice on a Hoarder

who's talking here?

Tee C 1
Cindy 1
overit 1
My4Kids 2
Rebel Starz 4
a2840298uu 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Rebel Starz --- 15 years ago -

ok. Ive posted here before that we are living in gramma's basement apartment to prevent her from going into a senior home and to help her out with things she has no buisness doing. i do enjoy it here, were alone when we want to be and when we want company we have it.

let me say that i have OCD when it comes to cleaning, organizing, and having things in order im a perfectionist at it and gramma is a bit of a hoarder. she keeps everything, even if she personally has no use for. she says she keeps things incase someone needs them which i understand...but when the entire family DOESNT want it she still finds a space to tuck it away. its gotten worse since we moved in and now the room that is supposed to be my daughters room when she comes and visits is busting at the seams with just crap.

im the type of person that if i havent used it in 6 months (not seasonal stuff) or have no intention anymore to use something then i give it away. im a frequent giver on freecycle and craigslist. i know that this is my personal way of things but was just giving you an insight on how i deal with my crap. when it comes to sentimental value then theres no question about it i will keep it but i dont keep every little piece that someone has ever given me.

for example. theres a desk and chair that was given to her and the chair part is broken and the legs are split and cracked. she doesnt want to get rid of it bc of them being given to her together. even though its broken and would cost more to redo it vs. buying another one she keeps it. she also has a microwave from like 1960 and kept it bc it still works but everyone already has a brand new one within the last year...she even researched it and you cant find parts to it from that yr so if it broke it would be pointless. she has paint thats older then my husband lol

i guess i just dont quite understand on keeping things like that for so long that are broken and stuff. i understand sentimental value and "the grandkids will use it when they get older" but other stuff im just not getting it. ive tried many time to tell her if she wanted to go through that room i would be more then happy to help her since she shouldnt be lifting things on her own and we went through and drug out so much stuff that she decided she didnt want and of course i wasnt needing it either and it seems like it didnt do anything when it came to emptying the room for my daughter. just curious is anyone has ever had to deal with this and what did you do and just basically any advice. my nerves are driving me crazy lol...HELP! lol 

My4Kids --- 15 years ago -

Hoarding is a type of mental disorder classified under OCD. Like you might have the compulsiveness to clean she has the compulsiveness to hang onto things. Most of the time people hoard as a way to drown out their emotions much like an alcoholic or drug user would. Most times it is spurred from a traumatic experience such as a death of a loved one. There is also not much reasoning when it comes to this. Unless she realizes it is a problem then there is no way to 'treat' the situation. Acceptance is the key to treating anything. You say she is your gramma so I assume she is up there in age so just know that sometimes if this has not been a on going situation, it could be linked to something like dementia/alzheimer's disease.

My dad had Alzheimer's disease and he started hoarding things as his disease progressed. It never got to the point of over excessive although before anyone caught on he had Alzheimer's he had maxed out credit cards and spent his savings on useless things. When he died I had to sell out his house and property to cover his funeral and expenses. It was a horrible situation and experience. 

Rebel Starz --- 15 years ago -

Unless she realizes it is a problem then there is no way to 'treat' the situation.


she cracks me up. she always talks about how she doesnt know what all she has and needs to get rid of some stuff but when i offer my help and say "gramma lets do this!" lol she find a reason why she needs to keep it. like earlier...i found some old pantry doors and asked her about them and she said she would find a place, again in the room, to stash them bc she cant see getting rid of wood that is still good. when we just tore down a huge pantry for the wood so husband could build me a fishtank stand and our trailor outside is stacked high with wood lol. would it be wrong of me to get rid of it without her knowing? i mean its just wood...and its not like we dont have enough outside...

i love her to death and im trying to accept the fact that she collects stuff but i feel its to much and some needs to go bc where is my daughter going to sleep and play when she visits? 

overit --- 15 years ago -

Have you tried to explain about your concerns about your daughter to her? Maybe see if there is a deal you can work out with her? 

Rebel Starz --- 15 years ago -

Have you tried to explain about your concerns about your daughter to her? Maybe see if there is a deal you can work out with her?

yea we both have and all she says is that it just needs to be reorganized which is true but also the broken and useless stuff needs to be put outside. i told her that even though we dont need it or the rest of the family has no use for it...some stranger may need it and WOULD use it. so in a way she would be getting rid of it but letting someone else use it for the rest of its time but it doesnt seem to help any. :( i just hate clutter lol 

a2840298uu --- 15 years ago -

you should watch the show hoarders. when i seen people that had there homes jam packed with stuff i just thought they were dirty or hoosiers, but after watching that show i learned (like the person listed above) it really is a sickness, and it usually cant be fixed over night. now when i see a house that is stuffed full, it saddens me, i wish i could help them. 

Cindy --- 15 years ago -

Don't try and throw something away. She WILL know and she will know you did it. Especially in a situation like this you want her to feel like she can trust you. There's no way you can just take away a thing or two until her house is clean.

I recommend convincing her (gently) to visit with a therapist who could help her but she has to realize she has a problem before any progress can be made. 

Tee C --- 15 years ago -

There is no way to convince a hoarder to let things go without a grand awakening or professional help. Think about the fellow on the show whose wife actually fell down the stairs and injured herself very badly because his items were strewn about; she also had a heart attack from the stress. Well, he still didn't stop his hoarding habit. A hoarder doesn't have the same thought pattern as someone who doesn't hoard; hoarders see value in everything, even if it's a hairball or used Q-tip (and they can justify keeping everything they hoard).

Like Cindy said, no amount of convincing on your part could get Grams to stop her habit; as a matter of fact, it could cause her habit to kick into overdrive because it can make her feel threatened. Suggesting a storage facility may help (but it could also just give her fresh room to hoard as well). Blessings to you; I have a hoarder in my family and it took a tragedy to get her sorted out :(. 

Rebel Starz --- 15 years ago -

Suggesting a storage facility may help


she has 2 8x8 sheds with crap already. im a regular watcher of the show but it seems like this situation is different...maybe just bc its real family. her suggestion on how to fix the clutter was to take out the hallway and add that to the room so i would be able to cut the room in half for my daughter. so basically making the room bigger. not really feeling that bc i dont want people who go up or down the stairs to have to enter my room or another room.

like i said certain things i understand in keeping...but things like the 1960 microwave that you cant buy parts for anymore i mentioned above, whats the point? nobody wants it so give it away where someone who needs one can get to it! 

My4Kids --- 15 years ago -

Rebel I feel your pain, I do because my father in law is one of those that also says "got to hang onto it... might need it". Even if its a twisty tie off the bread...he keeps it. Their house is soooo cluttered with JUNK! When we visit we lose so much stuff because it falls inbetween the boxes or msc. items in the bedrooms. I could NEVER live there but you are living with it. I understand it may not be an option to move but you might have to come to accept that it is her house and try to work around it the best you can. The more you push the issue the more aggitated she will become.

My best suggestion is to start with reorganization. If she will accept help to move the items in to an organized fashion. This means buying rubbermaid totes and boxes and basically let her put the items in them. For everything else like wood or extras that could make it outside, suggest putting those in the sheds outside. By reorganizing the outside sheds you should have room. I would not suggest telling her or even suggesting to get rid of them at this point but the process of reorganization might help keep your sanity, give you room and also feed her need to keep them.

Good luck! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Riley Underground