Riley Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Riley bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for sale near Fort Riley courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Offensive: Should there continue to be "race" history months?

who's talking here?

emily 1
$$BahamianDiva$$ 6
Tiffany 1
Hope 2
BadLuckMommy 3
josie 2
Blondie 1
Louis Lane 1
hillzzwife01 3
JeffandKristen 6
-NewYoRican- 1
Madonna 1
LilMrsNelson 1
Elizabeth 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

JeffandKristen --- 16 years ago -

I am asking this question to see what others have to say. I want to know if others believe there should be a history month for all races besides Caucasian or should there be a Caucasian history month, or should all months be done away with. I personally believe that either all months should be done away with or there should be a Caucasian month, just because I feel if anyone is being "oppressed" it's because they are oppressing themselves.  

JeffandKristen --- 16 years ago -

Im not being prejudice im just saying....trying to point out..please no one take it the wrong way 

BadLuckMommy --- 16 years ago -

I think it should stand as is, no need to change History. Ive heard this discussion from people at work, people at school, and my own family (we are from the south) I think every holiday that is recognized is because there is history and reasoning behind it. 

LilMrsNelson --- 16 years ago -

^ I agree. Its our nations history. 

Tiffany --- 16 years ago -

I agree Kristen. My daughter has asked me if we had a history month like her friend does. If a kids recognizes the absence it's pretty obvious. 

Louis Lane --- 16 years ago -

I have to say that when a certain ethnicity of people says that they arent treated right how is it fair to celebrate them in there own holiday where inevitably people will put them down for there culture and beliefs, thats very true wheres caucasion (sorry) day? but i do have to admit that I dont think racism especially in this country will fade anytime soon, No biggy tho in the end loves blind : ) 

-NewYoRican- --- 16 years ago -

I think it should stand as is, no need to change History Totally agree, The reason why we celebrate Hispanic month is because of cultural, political, economic, and artistic contributions to many to name as well as an historical legacy and residency that dates back to times before most of the states were admitted to the union... 

$$BahamianDiva$$ --- 16 years ago -

Caucasion Holidays: Christmas Independence Day Columbus Day Presidents Day St. Patricks Day...the list goes on 80% of school curriculum teaches the contributions of Caucasions. This is normal because this is America which is approx. 60-75% Caucasion. The small percentage of ethnic history taught will not endanger European culture as a whole. I believe it should stand, the only reason it is taught separate is because many teachers ad districts refused to include ethnic history in their curriculum up until the 1970s, and some want it gone today, hince Arizona. Much of it is valuable, such as who inveted the stoplight and for our husbands, the man who invented the Gas mask. i.e. Garrett A. Morgan 

Elizabeth --- 16 years ago -

Independence day is not a "Caucasian Holiday" it is a day that ALL AMERICANS celebrate our freedom. Presidents day is no longer a Caucasian Holiday Christmas is technically a Christian Holiday Columbus day is a celebration of our GREAT COUNTRY being discovered. St. Patty's Day is an Irish Holiday And the list goes on....... 

Elizabeth --- 16 years ago -

Also if we have a holiday for certain ethnicities we should have one for all so where is the Asian, Middle Eastern, ect. Holidays or months?? 

BadLuckMommy --- 16 years ago -

Columbus day actually is celebrated by my culture more especially because he was Italian! Italians are not caucasians but considered hispanic. Its actually a day celebrated because America was discovered. Christmas....well that's more of a religious celebration more then a race celebration. Independence Day.... When America declared its independence St. Patricks day... For the Irish Caucasian Americans Don't have a holiday that teaches what the american caucasians did in the past. Its all in History, but it doesn't focus specifically on caucasians. I still think nothing needs to be changed. 

JeffandKristen --- 16 years ago -

Is it the fault of the Caucasians that we have achieved a great deal? Like I said, it is racism not to have one race or all races. I personally think we should break down these barriers that we have set for ourselves and achieve new greatness. 

Hope (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

Kristen I can see what you are saying and I think that as long as their are exclusions such as certain races being excluded from months it shows discrimination at a subconsious level...what not honor all as all are human beings and all have history and heritage that can be learned to help all better understand.Take each month and honor all accomplishments and achievements and history and dont leave anyone out..I dont see how that can hurt anyone. I wouldnt want to remove the months as I think they serve a purpose for understanding and pride, but why honor only some races above others is discriminating and all people are equal & should be honored for what they have accomplished. I would find myself hard pressed to explained if asked by my kids why only certain family members have months to explain their heritage. How can you explain it without the terms discrimination or exclusion. 

Blondie --- 16 years ago -

No matter what anyone says, I am pretty appalled that we don't have our own month to celebrate. Most holidays have to do with religious or historic celebrations, but if you look, there is no month dedicated to caucasians. 

josie --- 16 years ago -

Caucasion Holidays: Christmas Independence Day Columbus Day Presidents Day St. Patricks Day...the list goes on This just made me laugh because it's so far from the truth. I AM caucasian, and don't understand how any of those are seen as Caucasian Holidays. Last time I checked, non-white people celebrated Christmas, Independence day, Presidents Day AND Columbus Day. And St Pattys Day is for the Irish, not ALL white people. This is why these kinds of debates get so heated, because people post responses like that and just start trouble. Is it annoying that we don't have Caucasian History Month? Umm, sure. Is it annoying that I need to 'Press 1 for English'... ABSO-freakin-Lutely. But just because there is no dedicated month, doesnt mean you cant choose a time and celebrate it and talk to your own kids about it. Its a topic that is always going to have big debates. If you feel as strongly as it sounds like you do, get involved and take it to whoever our local congress person is. All of these 'Months' and some holidays came to be because someone, somewhere, opened their mouth and MADE it that way. I'm sure you'd have alot of supporters. 

$$BahamianDiva$$ --- 16 years ago -

Caucasion- Europid, decendents of European ancestry. Irish, Greek, etc all Europid. Africans in America were not independent or free when America fought and won independence. Christmas, although Christ derived from the Kemur (a trinity based religion in ancient Africa) was not an African teaching until later. President's Day was initially created to celebrate the birthday of George Washtington who owned over 300 slaves himself. President Lincoln's name wasn't added until the 1980s. I agree we don't need a dedicated month, the month was created by Carter G Woodson to celebrate the birthdays of Frederick Douglass and President Abraham Lincoln. I feel that people should teach their own kids and no month is needed. We all know that people wouldn't teach their kids about other cultures in a fair ad honest light...let's not lie to ourselves.Blacks often teach their kids to be fearful and distrusting of whites and whites often teach their kids to be fearful and distrusting of blacks. We teach our kids based on our fear and not facts and that is the real problem that has yet to be solved. WE ALSO HAVE WOMEN'S history month should we get rid of that? Press 1 for English is not annoying to me because I believe in what America really means. We are a nation of immigrants and refugees and the uniqueness of multiple cultures ad ideas is what makes us the Greatest Nation on God's green earth. "Give me your tired, your poor, Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free," -On the Statue of Liberty 

$$BahamianDiva$$ --- 16 years ago -

The point is we are all under the illusion that we are so advanced that we don't need culture based teachint in America. The truth is, in our homes we don't teach our children enough about other cultures, we pretend that we are all the same, by saying things like, "We are all human" etc. Although this cliche is true there are cultural differences among us that we should teahc our children, but we should teach them that cultural differences do not make people inferior or superior, but just different, instead we all want to pretend that every human is the same, passing on this illusion to our children. 

hillzzwife01 --- 16 years ago -

Although this cliche is true there are cultural differences among us that we should teahc our children, but we should teach them that cultural differences do not make people inferior or superior, but just different, instead we all want to pretend that every human is the same, passing on this illusion to our children. well said. i myself am white and don't think we need a month dedicated to ourselves. we've had many things in the past that other races were not entitled to, therefor why do we also need a special month? IMO it sounds like a sense of entitlement. on the other hand white is not quite a real race. if someone were to establish a month for caucasians what would it be for? a white person is mostly some type of european mutt lol. me being irish, german, english and italian. so what background would the caucasian month actually celebrate? someones background would get left out and it would be a heated topic all over again. 

Hope (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

The truth is, in our homes we don't teach our children enough about other cultures, this is not true for all as some families have varied heritages ...my kids know they have a step grandfather that is hispanic and my sister 1/2 black, and native american from my moms side of the family.. my kids see only their family If they have questions I will answer it but i dont feel the need to point out "differences" based on race..this is not always the case but why instill that into them when they see no difference ...I have met many an @$$hole growing up that had something to say about my family from all sides a person cant change everyone in the world but all you can do is your part and im trying to teach my children that all people are equal ... but we are still far from that as long as people cant see even the exclusion of some races in heritage months. oh well some will get offended by even this post. 

JeffandKristen --- 16 years ago -

If you want to bring up slaves, Africans were probably the shortest period of being slaves here in America. Every culture has gone through being slaves, whites, blacks, hispanics, asian, and the list goes on and on. I personally have never owned a slave so the fact that that point keeps getting brought up is kinda annoying to me. If anyone in history has received the short end of a stick, I think the Jews have the most right to talk, they have been slaves for the world LITERALLY, millions were executed, and they still don't have a home! Israel, but even that is being fought to be taken away. They are the only group that so many dictators of the world have sworn to destroy. As for Christ, Christ was taught in all over the world so Christmas would be a celebration for all of us. I personally am white yes, and proud to be white. I don't know my heritage, I personally don't care. I was born and raised in the U.S.A. So I am American. We are still racially divided as a Country, and there's end in sight. I will probably catch grief from this, but I think our Country is anti-white. NAACP, BET, JET, Colleges for every group besides white only. I understand that people were "oppressed" but as I have stated, If you are being "oppressed" you are oppressing yourself. You are wrong about the cultures teachings also. I do talk to me kids about cultures, cause we can learn things from other cultures, and they can from us. My son is learning spanish, another culture besides "white" We went from segregating people in the 1960's into segregating people. Sure Women, the Japanese in the 1940's, Hispanics that are currently used as "slaves", Blacks in the 1960's.....I got it, but we are still segregated and people are scared to stand up and be proud they are white. Why? Because society has given a stigma attached to "whites" that you can't be proud without being racist. Well I am not racist towards anyone, every culture has their good and their trash. This is why I ask this question routinely to everyone to see what they say. Thanks for ya'lls inputs! I really like reading peoples opinions, being very opinionated myself. 

hillzzwife01 --- 16 years ago -

I will probably catch grief from this, but I think our Country is anti-white. NAACP, BET, JET, Colleges for every group besides white only. I understand that people were "oppressed" but as I have stated, If you are being "oppressed" you are oppressing yourself. i would imagine that there are not colleges for whites only is because white people are not denied education just because they are white, as i know some colleges still deny people of color. if there was a college for whites only it would be a slap in the face for anyone who battled segregation throughout the 50's, 60's and even the 70's. as for naacp, bet and jet why shouldn't those be in effect? jet is a magazine where black models can get covers always. where if you look at other publications it is rare to see a black model on the cover. only once in awhile, which is sad. We are still racially divided as a Country, and there's end in sight. obviously there is not an end in sight if you think it's a good idea to open a whites only college. thats a small step away from other "white only" business' opening. then where are we? back to the beginning. this is just my opinion though. i'm not trying to start a drama-fied discussion lol. 

JeffandKristen --- 16 years ago -

The point I was making is the exact opposite of the way I meant it. I mean that there shouldn't be months, holidays, magazines, TV's, Colleges, Grants...ect. ect. I also don't agree with Affirmative Action, another form of racism. I understand that at one point and time, it was hard times for everyone, but that was probably before any of us were alive. The time is now to break down these barriers. But we have to do it together and not be so naive or closed minded towards ALL races. As for drama, I hope you don't take anything I say as drama, and as the person that started this thread, I don't want drama, I want opinions. Another thing that I believe will bring us closer together. I am constantly trying to be corrected about talking about Politics, Religion, Race...ect, But I don't get mad at peoples stand points, except for complete ignorance of course, such groups as KKK, Nazi's, Panthers, or any of those, cause I do find complete racism ignorant. But we all are prejudice against something or someone, we just need to accept it. Thanks again....:) 

hillzzwife01 --- 16 years ago -

But we have to do it together and not be so naive or closed minded towards ALL races. agreed! 

$$BahamianDiva$$ --- 16 years ago -

I will probably catch grief from this, but I think our Country is anti-white. NAACP, BET, JET, Colleges for every group besides white only. I understand that people were "oppressed" but as I have stated, If you are being "oppressed" you are oppressing yourself. BET is owned by VIACOM which is not blacks, The black colleges ironically were created by white christian missionaries who sought to help blacks learn to read and write after slavery, none of these things were created by blacks. These were handouts bought about by Americas' guilt. JET is a magazine, if you've got a story that you want to get in these submit it to the publishers, or the company that owns JET which is also not a black owned company. Many companies have used racially charged demographics in order to increase sales. We never look through this hinceforth blaming whites or blacks or hispanics. One company owns a t.v. station that is "black" so others complain, then they creat another to satify the others (increasing sales again). We all go for it, only one school that was founded by blacks and that was MOrris Brown College which was formed by a former slave turned preacher who had learned to read and write. All of the others were donated by white Christian organization, and most up until the mid 1900s, had black students, but white professors, deans, staff, etc. Don't let the media hype black this and black that fool you. It is all an illusion created to make more money, and when they're done making money with it they use it to create what Reagan called "white blacklash" in order to increase their votes. Many of America's schools are predomniantly white, UCLA, UCSD, San Diego State, Kansas State; U of Kansas, etc. Most of those so called black schools are only about 80% black, whites and hispanics are applying much more. In fact about a year or two ago Morehouse college had a white valedictorian. 

Madonna --- 16 years ago -

ok i have to say that there were some REALLY great opinions, no no one is being offensive or racist, for what he or she has said. but with that being said; me being of a multicultural background, i see all ends of the stick, i had never experienced racism until i had moved to the united states (VA,FL,GA) to be exact. we are still in a culturally divided world and it is sad. what i have to say is this, when it comes to schools and such Caucasian scholarships there are: Name CU-LEAD Scholarship Francis C. Arthur Scholarship Mr. and Mrs. Skip Bean Scholarship Stefan Allan Zweig Memorial Scholarship thats just a few... there is also a an article about a "whites only scholarship" Scholarship and there are many others. if you look at the statistics in schools the schools from grade school all the way up to college the numbers are predominantly white unless you go to the "ghetto" or the part of town where families don't make enough to afford the rent. so education is not necessarily divided, its all about if the colored people can make it into a world with different opportunities... meaning, for instance, growing up when i moved to the states, i would always hear friend parents talking to their kids, and their friends about naming kids. never really thought much about it then but, they used to always say when you have kids make sure you give them a good name and not a "ghetto name" didn't make sense now, but here is why. employers, judge you on everything now, from the wording you use in your resume down to your name, it's not just based on personal appearance anymore, because there are so many things they have to their advantage. the name you put on your resume can hut you, like if you had a kid and you named them shaquanna, terell, shantell and any other name you can think of that you may of heard since you were in school, automatically they think black. but when you put a name like madonna, molly, miranda amanda,dave, bryan, david, and so on, there is no issue. same thing for carlos, juan, julio and so forth. not blaming parents or society. its just still the world we live in. when you look at me and my family you see many different skin colors. some as pale as white. some naturally tan, many of them are Indian, so they wear the clothes and the head wraps from India.. so i get Taliban is in town when i'm with my grandfather's side of the family, or i get the "N" bomb when i'm with my dad and his family, or spick when i wear my hair curly lol. honestly i dont care. i love the way things are now because it gives each race something to work for. white people imo if coming from the right side of the tracks never really have much to worry about because they will get it, schools, jobs, money, careers, and so on, but if you grew up in a middle class type of lifestyle then not so much. no for If you want to bring up slaves, Africans were probably the shortest period of being slaves here in America. Every culture has gone through being slaves, whites, blacks, hispanics, asian, and the list goes on and on. I personally have never owned a slave so the fact that that point keeps getting brought up is kinda annoying to me. If anyone in history has received the short end of a stick, I think the Jews have the most right to talk, they have been slaves for the world LITERALLY, millions were executed, and they still don't have a home! Israel, but even that is being fought to be taken away. They are the only group that so many dictators of the world have sworn to destroy. As for Christ, Christ was taught in all over the world so Christmas would be a celebration for all of us. I personally am white yes, and proud to be white. i agree 100 percent. the black kids today that cry oppression have no right to talk in my opinion, because there are so many opportunities, that they have no reason to not to take them, many of them just choose to settle and that is their "cop out" the only people who have been oppressed and who should be celebrated are their ancestors and what they did to contribute to this country. not saying they don't have a right to express their own opinion, but just saying, that some of them could do more for themselves. i don't think anyone should look at this thread as a reason for drama, we are just discussing things that most politicians are scared to discuss. what most people won't say in mix company thats all. i agree with Bahamian diva, Europeans are the people we Call White or Caucasian, because all of our conquistador's and explorers came from Europe, and all people with European decent are considered to be white. BLM i understand what you mean about Italians, it confuses me because the world says people from Europe are considered white, but the consider people from Spain to be Latin?? i'm part Spaniard as well so i'm confused lol. honestly there will be nothing that we can do about it really because we live in a world where people dwell on the past more than they do on the future 

$$BahamianDiva$$ --- 16 years ago -

It is common practise for the powerful to create barriers between the less powerful majority to maintain their own power. We point the fingers at each other saying things like "They have this ad wont let me have that" "Or why is this special and special that" all the way they package and sale us these barriers and in exchange we give them our money at the box office or votes at the ballot boxes. We must demand that those who we hire to teach our childrenor vote in to make our laws see people as people. We've had issues with this recently, the internet has allowed those who have an un-American mission to spread their message at a faster rate, be it a backlash message or a black militancy message or an illegal immigrants are all that is evil message and we sign on and agree oftentimes when we should be saying halt, this is not true and there is a better way to make a better world. If we do not get a handle on our ow fears, and resentmet we will sit by idle as the next Hitler arises via facebook and twitter. All it takes is saying "Yeah I resent them too, yeah me too," next comes what do we do about it. Then it's form our own party to show our resentment, then it's we should be armed....and it slowly escalates. It has happened since the beginning of time. The rise of many hateful parties and people began with "We need to take our country back!" Let's be careful. 

$$BahamianDiva$$ --- 16 years ago -

I was just using the fact that Washington had slaves as fact, an example. I see slavery brings out emotion in people. I do agree that slavery in America was the shortest, but this is also easy to say for all of us who were't slaves for 4 or 5 geerations. To many 400-600 years is short, but to a mother raped who loses her children, one day seems like for ever. If you believe it is short the ask the many slaves who are being trafficked from country to country even today. I think there are many opportunities today, within the very communities that I grew up in that happen to be majority black and hispanic, this is because when you have a majority in your own districts then you hold power, with the votes, funds etc. In the same token my kids will grow up differently as military brats, which is good thing in ways and a bad thing in ways, because outside of the military the country is nowhere near as tolerant of each other and they will have to face that. 

JeffandKristen --- 16 years ago -

As I have stated, it is the shortest lived. There is still "slavery" being used today. Allow me to explain and I will go as to its being supported by everyone that will read this post. In Iraq you have Indian and Pakistani workers that make a dollar or so daily, not allowed to return to India or Pakistan and if they do then they are not allowed to come back. They work 7 days a week, 12hr days, 52 weeks a year for about 5-6 years. They can't go off the FOB and have no rights. This is a form of slavery to me, sure they are getting paid change which might equal a decent paycheck in their country but we allow them to be worked to the ground and not see their families. The way I know this? It's amazing what you learn in a year if you care enough to see it. The way it is supported because no one is allowed to ask questions anymore where their taxes are going. As for the trafficking I understand that I do not know what it is like and never will, but neither will anyone on here. We are the land of the free and home of the brave. 

BadLuckMommy --- 16 years ago -

All I have to say on this is the grass always seems greener on the other side. If you don't succeed its because you didn't try hard enough! I'm so tired of hearing how racism has a part in everything when in fact it has nothing to do with it. I am from the south, born in Montgomery Alabama raised in Georgia. Frankly I thing now and days its just an excuse. Do you realize that there are grants for several different races...just because I'm italian guess what, I get grants. There are opportunities made available to ALL races... 

josie --- 16 years ago -

i would imagine that there are not colleges for whites only is because white people are not denied education just because they are white, as i know some colleges still deny people of color Just an FYI- this is not accurate. There are schools all over the country that deny admission to 'whites' because they need to have a certain number of 'minorities' enrolled... so in those cases, yes, white people are denied admission to schools as well. It's really pathetic that people still say things like that. Discrimination happens to EVERYONE. I am a white, catholic female and I have been discriminated against 100's of times for multiple things. Discrimination is not only done by whites, or not only done by african americans, etc. It happens by everyone, to everyone... at one point or another. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Riley Underground