Riley Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Riley bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for sale near Fort Riley courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Annoying, Annoying, Annoying......... Parenting Question

who's talking here?

Proud Cav. Wife 5
FortRileyMom3 3
MaMi2oNe 1
army_eng_wife 1
*SoCal Princess* 1
giffs fam 3
GoingGreen 1
Blondie 1
Amanda 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Proud Cav. Wife --- 16 years ago -

So I was talking to a friend of my Mom's tonight, and she asked me if with my upcoming son's birth would I be nursing. I gave her the same response that I have given everyone: "If I feel like I can, I will. I know that a majority of women have a dead set plan and for various reasons they can't. I know several people that can't breastfeed because they don't produce, and others that can't because of the pain. I want too, but if I choose it just isn't for me then I wont"........ I then got a lecture for 30 minutes about how it was the best way, the right way and God's way. I need to breast feed and it is my duty as a Mom. I understand having a strong opinion, but here is my issue. It isn't just this person that told me all of this, I hear it from everyone. From the nurses at IACH, to family, to strangers that see my belly and want to talk about my son. I get it from friends, WIC and check out girls at the commissary. I don't understand how hard it is to just let me do what I want, and understand I actually am not decided either way. If I can't even produce anything am I supposed to let my Son starve because it isn't God's way? And what if I literally can't for some other reason, Should I be punished then? It isn't like Formula is Crack or anything. I have read all the studies, I know the benefits blah blah blah, Why do I need to know what YOU personally believe?? Sorry for the rant, I am just having a rough day. 

giffs fam --- 16 years ago -

ITs your choice rather you want to or not. ANd like you said what if you cant produce enough then you have to feed the baby formula. You dont have a CHoice I chose not to brestfeed so does that make me a bad person?? No it was just my personal choice. My husaband was mad at me he goes i want you to do a test since you didnt do it with our daughter i want you to do it with our son so i can prove to you he will turn out smart and the other one not as smart. I was like no im not doing it. Then he tried to tell me that look at him and his brother his litle brother. his little brother knows alot more than he does and his little brother is only 19 years old my husband is 25. I was like you cant even compare your little brother to you becuase he was brestfed and you were not becuase 1st off you 2 have 2 different dads. AND 2nd off your brother was raised buy a guy that knows ALOT!!!! LIke im not talking a little im talking ALOT. He knows everything to know about the bible to the point he could be a pastor and he hasnt even been to colege for it. HE has been to school for aviation, law infocemnt automotive ECT..... AND HIs little brothers dad started him on ABC's, Numbers and colors as soon as he could talk. So i was like dont blame it on becuase you were not brestfed blame it on having 2 different dads. 

*SoCal Princess* --- 16 years ago -

Ok, so I read the studies, blah blah when I was pregnant with my oldest. I dont believe a breastfed baby will be smarter, see better, whatever. Because my sisters son was breastfed, and mine wasnt. they are the same age and my daughter is so much smarter. Not saying my nephew is dumb but its just showing you that its not true. I think its ur decision and you as a mom have the natural instinct of whats best for not only the child but you as well. dont stress over it. im in a bad mood this morning so the only advice i can give is tell them to shove it where the sun dont shine. its ok to give advice, but not ok to try to make the decision for u. Its not even the hubbys decision. 

FortRileyMom3 --- 16 years ago -

Just dont elaborate with them. Just say "I have made my choice" They cant lecture you if you chose not to listen or talk back. Or just say "Ok thanks for sharing" and walk away. They will get the point when you turn your back on them. I know it seems rude but they are forcing their opinion on you and you dont want it. Thats rude too. 

Proud Cav. Wife --- 16 years ago -

To me it isn't even the arguments for or against that irritate me. I mean I read up on it all the time. Just like I read up on the pro's and con's of eating organic, or the best things to buy for your child. My problem mostly is that you can't just answer someone and have them accept it. They want to tell you why you are right, and why you are wrong. Even when I say "I'm on the fence until I try it for myself" I still get the "lectures". I just don't understand why everyone has to tie me to the steak just to prove their point. I guess I am just having one of those days! 

Proud Cav. Wife --- 16 years ago -

Just dont elaborate with them. Just say "I have made my choice" They cant lecture you if you chose not to listen or talk back. Or just say "Ok thanks for sharing" and walk away. They will get the point when you turn your back on them. I know it seems rude but they are forcing their opinion on you and you dont want it. Thats rude too. I think this is what I am going to have to start doing. You make a good point. 

FortRileyMom3 --- 16 years ago -

It will take a lot of self control on your part but sometimes it is just what you have to do. I remember being pregnant and people giving me advice and opinions that I didnt want and how angry it used to make me. Women believe that because they were pregnant and had a kid that makes them experts on it all. 

Proud Cav. Wife --- 16 years ago -

Women believe that because they were pregnant and had a kid that makes them experts on it all. That is so the truth! It seems as though as soon as I started showing I started getting flooded with all sorts of weird advice, and crazy ideals. 

army_eng_wife --- 16 years ago -

@giff has your hubby been deployed and hit? I know my hubby lost some up there afterbeing hit. Is his brother in military. That could be another strike why he is smarter (not being hit). Sounds like your hubby has deeper issues than just breastfeeding (no offense intended) 

giffs fam --- 16 years ago -

my husband has been deployed twice soon to be a 3rd but has never been hit. (The closest he has been to being hit was when a road side bomb hit a hum V 2 hum V's infront of the one he was in which was the 1st time he got deployed when he was with an infentry unit which he is now with aviation. HE has NOT come back with any mental issues (such as flash backs or anything like that) My Husband knows alot Becuase he spent his high school years being raised by his brothers dad) but his brother knows way more but like i said they have 2 different dads and his brother was raised a guy who knows ALOT His whole life where my husband got raised by this guy in his high school years( its not becuase one was breastfed and one wasnt which for some reason my husband wants to belive I think its just cuz he didnt want to spend the moeny on the formula lol)no my husbands brother isnt in the military yet. He is on probation at the moment but after he gets off probation he wants to join the navy seals. Here is another exampel with my husband and his brothers So that brother is way smarter becuase they have different dads and His brother was raised by his dad and my husbnad was raised by his mom. BUt LEts look at my husbands other brother who has the same dad but different moms. THat brother was also brestfed ANd my husband is way smarter than that brother. So im with SP I dont think brest feeding makes a child smarter. I think it depends on when the parent Starting teaching them Like i said my brother in laws dad started him on abc's 123's and colors as soon as he could talk so he knew all that before he even started pre school at the age of 4. And even tho that brother is 19 he continues to educate him on things he may not know. The little sister fromt hat same dad thats only 6 years old Is always asking questiosn like what you doing? Well whats that for and he will explain it to her. I think she is so annyoing asking when you are dongi something what are you doing? Why are you donig that? Well what is that for? But All she doing is trying to educate herself and her dad lets her ask all these questions. If i got asekd all those questions by my children i wouldnt ever get anything done. Altho at the same time they are learning 

Amanda --- 16 years ago -

I hate when ppl lecture about breastfeeding...I never breastfed my daughter and she is a smart little thing. I think it is definitely a personal choice and only YOU can make it. I don't produce milk at all aside form the colostrum when they are first born so she never had a chance. I have no intention of trying with my son now cause I know the outcome and it's a waste of my time. People can lecture you all day but you don't have to listen to them. I would just walk away :) 

FortRileyMom3 --- 16 years ago -

All of my girls were bottle fed from day one. They are all 4.0 students, two are gifted (the middle one would be if she would apply herself, she is actually smarter than the other two). We instilled in them from a young age the importance of learning and learning all you can. We both love to read so they like to read. They all read way above their grade level. So if I breast fed them they would be Einsteins right? LOL 

GoingGreen --- 16 years ago -

I think it's personal choice and no one should be treated like a horrible mother if they choose not to breastfeed. My daughter was only breast fed for two weeks and then went to formula. She is very intelligent at only 18months, I am impressed with how much she knows and it drives me crazy when I hear that breastfed babies are smarter because that is just crap. My nephews were never breastfed and they make all A's in school. I could only breastfeed for two weeks because I got really sick and I couldn't eat for about a week so I stopped producing enough milk for my daughter. I will say though that those two weeks that I did breastfeed were the most stressful two weeks of my life! It was just very hard for me to do so when I put her on the bottle I became such a better mommy! I was so relieved. I will breastfeed for a few weeks with my next baby but after that he or she will go to formula. I also hear that babies that are breastfed are healthier well my sister in law breast fed all three of her kids and they get sick ALLLLLL the time. You know what's best for your child and you will make the right decision for him and for you. 

giffs fam --- 16 years ago -

I also hear that babies that are breastfed are healthier Yup i have heard that too and i think thats BS My friend brestfed all 4 of her kids and they all 4 get sick all the time Why becuase they are picking up germs at the stoere at school from the kids she does daycare for ECT. Regardless of brestfeeding its not goign to make your child healtier becuase they are still going to pick up those germs 

MaMi2oNe --- 16 years ago -

PCW I know exactly what you mean. Luckily I didn't have too much problem with this. The only one's that really pressured me was WIC that I can really remember. I say pressured because that is what it felt like, not informative conversation with pros and cons that would give me some insight to make my own personal decision, but one sided. I did decide to try it in the hospitol, but he wouldn't really take to it and for a few other reasons I decided it wasn't for us, but I tried. I did go to a breastfeeding class beforehand that was helpful and informative. One good point that I remember them saying was, even if you don't breastfeed or only if you do it for a few days, even that little bit is good for your baby. Something about nutrients being really strong or something in the first few days, I can't remember exactly. In the end, it's your own personal decision and people should learn to respect that. As for the truths and myths of breastfed babies being smarter, it was funny to read the posts on this, gave me a good laugh. I'm no Doogie Howser and wasn't breastfed, but I think I'm smart enough and never have been considered stupid :0) 

Proud Cav. Wife --- 16 years ago -

I don't know how you could even know if it makes someone smarter or not. First of all there are so many factors, Child's natural ability, Their environment, their up bringing, parents and drive. My brother is more driven than I am, so you could say he is smarter. I just don't apply myself to academics. You would literally need twins, and would need to breast feed one and not the other. You would have to keep all other factors the same, and they would both need the same drive for academia. To me I just can't see these studies having all variables under control enough to say one way or another that a child would be more intelligent with breast milk. 

Blondie --- 16 years ago -

As long as a child is loved and taken care of that is all I care about. I breastfeed but I am by all means NOT a breastfeeding nazi as they call them, LOL. There are some people shocked that I still breastfeed my daughter who just turned 10 months old and then I hear criticism from other people about planning to wean her by 12 months old because it's recommended to nurse until 2yrs old. The way I see it..if I nurse her til she's 1yr old that is a huge accomplishment. I do it just because it's a choice that I made from the beginning just like how some people make the choice to not breastfeed. As parents we have the right to care for our children how we see fit and it's no one else's business. I commend you for sticking by your own plans and not someone else's. It's a fight even for breastfeeding mothers as well. Just think about the nasty looks I get when I nurse my daughter in public even though she is totally covered and no one can see or even get a chance to see my chest. It's definitely a battle. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

parenting

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Riley Underground